I’m the same way
@jamgolf — the closer I get to making a decision on something like this, the more my heart makes the decision over my head.
I was doing some more value math (because I need new hobbies for my Sunday morning) and the discussion here about “on the road” costs got me curious so I looked into that in my current province of residence. My previous ideal specification runs about $136k or so on the configurator. I learned this morning that my current province has a variable sales tax depending on the price of the car, and the federal government takes a flat cut too. At my ideal spec level, that total tax is 20%, making my Grenadier cost $163,000.00.
I am within about 10% off being able to buy 2 Land Rover New Defenders ordered in my ideal spec for the cost of one Grenadier here in British Columbia, taxes in. My ideal spec is the best off road and towing specs, sun roof for taking pretty pictures of deadly animals and that’s about it. The New Defender comes with a lot more luxury for these prices, but it would substantively do the same kind of application as what the Gren would do.
In short, practically speaking the Grenadier is twice as expensive as the Defender here.
To @Xrford’s point about durability — given what I purchased my current rig for, I could get 5 of them with enough cash left over to travel for 3 months on my budget. That’s a lot of spares. If I assume these rigs will last a VERY conservative 200,000 kms - and they should do that easily with no concerns about the engine or transmission or other big ticket items causing problems — that means the Gren has to last me one million kilometres with nothing but fluid changes and tires for it to be a good value purchase in my context. If I get the more realistic 300,000 kms out of my current rig - which I should; I’ve had quite a few adventure vehicles and all but the Jeep made it past 300k without needing any major work — the Gren would need to give me 1,500,000 kilometres on the same drivetrain with just fluids and tires. Or 1.8 million kilometres if I include my current truck on top of the 5 I could get for $160k+.
This is math - there’s no denying the cost/benefit analysis here. And I don’t know if a single BMW product ever that lasted more than a million kms - certainly not their engines!
So it’s objectively bad value in Canada, but honestly after thinking about this thing for years, and currently only having a reservation and no real skin in the game that I cannot walk away from — if I was sitting on $160k it would still be a very tough decision to make, and in the end I’d likely still go for it
. That’s how much this damn thing has my heart.
Long story short,
@jamgolf, I hear you on wanting to avoid further temptation!!
Also, for folks thinking of cancelling in “The Home of the Brave” — maybe the Gren coming to the USA for 10k -15k more than most expected isn’t too bad after all; I think your actually not getting bad value down there. I, on the other hand, am in the “True North Strong and Expensive” apparently