The Grenadier Forum
Register Now for enhanced site access.
INEOS Agents, Dealers or Commercial vendors please contact admin@theineosforum.com for a commercial account.

Americas Don't buy a Grenadier (Steering pump noise and HVAC issues)

Lars

Grenadier Owner
Local time
10:12 AM
Joined
May 19, 2022
Messages
120
Reaction score
191
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
PSA:
I see that the power steering reservoir cap shows the required fluid as being “CHF”. CHF is a very specific hydraulic system fluid.
Isn't it interesting that it is so important, but nowhere in the owner's manual does it mention or specify CHF11. There is also a CHF202 fluid out there. If it wasn't for this forum would we know?
 

IdahoGrenadier

Grenadier Owner
Local time
11:12 AM
Joined
May 15, 2024
Messages
50
Reaction score
79
Location
Boise, ID, USA
PSA:
I see that the power steering reservoir cap shows the required fluid as being “CHF”.

Yeah, not having owned a European car since my 1979 VW Bus, my thought process went:
1) "huh, looks like my CHF fluid is bubbling over"
Then progressed to:
2) "what the hell is CHF fluid?"
 

Skydance

Grenadier Owner
Local time
6:12 PM
Joined
May 16, 2023
Messages
482
Reaction score
603
Location
MANCHESTER

dreamalaska

Lifetime Supporter
Local time
9:12 AM
Joined
Feb 15, 2024
Messages
159
Reaction score
202
Location
Anchorage, Alaska, USA
I topped mine up with

FUCHS TITAN CHF 11S Steering and Central Hydraulic Oil 1 Litre - Formerly Pentosin

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B07VRTCXCH/?tag=globalgrena0b-20
However, it still leaks out of the top. Wipe it away and it’s there again next time. I can’t understand why it comes out. No other BMW I’ve owned is the same. https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B07VRTCXCH/?tag=globalgrena0b-20
That’s the stuff. If CHF11S is not called out specifically in the owners manual, then maybe INEOS sourced the power steering fluid reservoir from a supplier who just used their existing twist cap. But I doubt that mistake would’ve been overlooked.

Regardless, CHF11S is good stuff. Use something else where it’s required then be willing to embrace the warning “FAFO”…
 

zvakanaka

Grenadier Owner
Local time
1:12 PM
Joined
May 30, 2022
Messages
131
Reaction score
142
Location
Florida
I've loved everything about the philosophy behind the Grenadier. 1,500 miles in and it's great off-road, looks great on road, and tows 6k pounds like a dream. I was willing to overlook the embarrassingly bad software that means button presses don't get recognized, it takes 30 seconds every time to turn off the speed clicker, and Android Auto disconnects every time you cross a lane line without the turn signal on.

But I've got to say you shouldn't buy one. My power steering pump makes a horrible whine that keeps me from driving with the windows down. (A separate whistle from the blend door prevents running the AC on full.) I get so many great comments when the engine is off. But when it's running, everyone asks me about the embarrassing, obviously-not-right whine from the pump. IA has told my dealer it's normal, even though some of them don't make it and no other vehicle I've ever heard makes this sound unless the lines weren't bled or the vane is going out.

Others on the forum have the same problem. Unlike the software and blend door, which IA acknowledges and promises a future fix, they are refusing to consider this obvious defect a problem. And that means the warranty is not worth anything.

So I gotta say regretfully, if you are on the fence, don't buy it.
So very sorry you’ve experienced these issues but I must say most of us haven’t had any or just a few problems, actually shocking since it’s a new manufacturer and a new vehicle so one could expect some issues but I for one have had zero.
 

SkiBum1

GG-4567
Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
12:12 PM
Joined
Nov 20, 2023
Messages
251
Reaction score
512
Location
Chicago, IL, USA
I don't mind the early adopter issues. The audacity of the project is something I wanted to support and be a part of. But when 100% of people who see the vehicle know there's something wrong and IA tries to say it's normal, that does have a JLR feel. Maybe this old Toyota guy just can't make the transition into that world.
There are a lot less problems than you suspect. Most people have no issues at all.
 

SkiBum1

GG-4567
Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
12:12 PM
Joined
Nov 20, 2023
Messages
251
Reaction score
512
Location
Chicago, IL, USA
There are exactly as many problems as I suspect. I've only referred to problems with my own vehicle in this thread.
Completely understand and I am sorry you have issues. I wish your experience was the same as mine. My dealer is great (although quite a drive) and I haven’t had any issues at all.
 

IdahoGrenadier

Grenadier Owner
Local time
11:12 AM
Joined
May 15, 2024
Messages
50
Reaction score
79
Location
Boise, ID, USA
Completely understand and I am sorry you have issues. I wish your experience was the same as mine. My dealer is great (although quite a drive) and I haven’t had any issues at all.
My dealer has also been good. My problem, as I stated at the beginning of the thread, is not with the vehicle's teething problems or dealer service. In fact, I'm amazed that they are building a new vehicle as effectively as they are. The assumption I made, however, is that the trade we were getting for buying a new brand with no track record was that we'd get problems fixed, if sometimes it took a little patience. That's why I'm disappointed in the software and HVAC issues but willing to give some benefit of the doubt when they say they are working on a fix.

But if they are going to say it's normal for a vehicle's steering system to be louder than the engine and insist they all do it when they clearly don't all do it, then it would be unreasonable to assume the company will stand by the rest of the vehicle.

I'm glad you haven't had issues with your vehicle. But I started this thread because prospective buyers and people who have not had problems with their vehicles should know how IA is responding to those of us with issues.

I want IA to be successful and not join Jaguar and Land Rover as British brands that Americans make fun of for bad quality control and worse support.
 

Jackattack13

Grenadier Owner
Local time
10:12 AM
Joined
Jan 18, 2024
Messages
273
Reaction score
388
Location
Carlsbad, CA, USA
Funny because I never noticed how loud the steering pump is until warm summer weather hit. Driving with windows down I was like, damn that high pitched noise is a bit much. Did nobody notice that during the initial testing of the prototype vehicles? It's particularly bad when next to something, like another car or a wall.
 

anand

Photo Contest Winner
Forum Moderator
Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
1:12 PM
Joined
Mar 12, 2023
Messages
3,137
Reaction score
5,087
Location
Maryland
Funny because I never noticed how loud the steering pump is until warm summer weather hit. Driving with windows down I was like, damn that high pitched noise is a bit much. Did nobody notice that during the initial testing of the prototype vehicles? It's particularly bad when next to something, like another car or a wall.
I'm pretty confident it was noticed and just accepted, all the PTO2 trucks had very loud PS pumps and we all learned to just accept it as the norm
 

DaveB

Grenadier Owner
Local time
4:12 AM
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
7,782
Reaction score
15,717
Location
Toogoom, Fraser Coast Queensland
I've loved everything about the philosophy behind the Grenadier. 1,500 miles in and it's great off-road, looks great on road, and tows 6k pounds like a dream. I was willing to overlook the embarrassingly bad software that means button presses don't get recognized, it takes 30 seconds every time to turn off the speed clicker, and Android Auto disconnects every time you cross a lane line without the turn signal on.

But I've got to say you shouldn't buy one. My power steering pump makes a horrible whine that keeps me from driving with the windows down. (A separate whistle from the blend door prevents running the AC on full.) I get so many great comments when the engine is off. But when it's running, everyone asks me about the embarrassing, obviously-not-right whine from the pump. IA has told my dealer it's normal, even though some of them don't make it and no other vehicle I've ever heard makes this sound unless the lines weren't bled or the vane is going out.

Others on the forum have the same problem. Unlike the software and blend door, which IA acknowledges and promises a future fix, they are refusing to consider this obvious defect a problem. And that means the warranty is not worth anything.

So I gotta say regretfully, if you are on the fence, don't buy it.
I spoke with Ineos today about a completely separate and non-vehicle issue.
I asked about noisy steering pump issues
They told me that it is definitely not normal and they would never tell someone that it is.
I am getting the feeling that some mainstream dealers around the world like to fall back on blaming the manufacturer.
We know that Ineos isn't perfect, or in some cases good, but it seems strange that some of us have a great response and others have a less than great response.

There have been people on here who have said they emailed Sir Jim, all the senior management, Jim's old headmaster, the vet that looks after King Charles horse, all with no response (not saying you did this) but be wary of dealers who blame the manufacturer.
 

hoohoohama

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
1:12 PM
Joined
Mar 26, 2023
Messages
112
Reaction score
81
Location
New York
I'm not messing with something that's wrong on a $90k vehicle because I don't want to give an excuse to say I exacerbated a problem. Especially with no service manuals. (I'll touch the stuff that's working fine plenty.) But this "normal" behavior that sounds like air in the system is now accompanied by reservoir overflowing that looks like air in the system.

The question is why are so many NA Grenadiers getting air in the system and where is it coming from? You know, or did IA just forget to bleed them and won't tell the dealers to spend 10 minutes on it?
My CHF oil reservoir also looks similar to your picture, presumably with some signs of leaking, what are we supposed to do in this case? Open the cap and try to top off? Not looking forward to schedule another appointment with dealership.
 

IdahoGrenadier

Grenadier Owner
Local time
11:12 AM
Joined
May 15, 2024
Messages
50
Reaction score
79
Location
Boise, ID, USA
I spoke with Ineos today about a completely separate and non-vehicle issue.
I asked about noisy steering pump issues
They told me that it is definitely not normal and they would never tell someone that it is.
I am getting the feeling that some mainstream dealers around the world like to fall back on blaming the manufacturer.
We know that Ineos isn't perfect, or in some cases good, but it seems strange that some of us have a great response and others have a less than great response.

There have been people on here who have said they emailed Sir Jim, all the senior management, Jim's old headmaster, the vet that looks after King Charles horse, all with no response (not saying you did this) but be wary of dealers who blame the manufacturer.

I reached out directly to IA on this and after collecting information from me they did a variety of "make the customer give up" stalling. After continuing to press, this is the response they ended with:
"Looking into your request further with our team, the information provided by the dealership on the service report you have provided is all we can recommend at this time as there are no fixes available."

My dealer circled back with them after this and now Ineos is going to have them replace my pump once all the seals and fluids are received at my dealer. We'll see what that does.

Still no recognition from IA that this is a problem.

Dealers can be a pain in the ass, but I made sure it was an IA problem before I called them out. And if the shame campaign is working, then I can only say I'm glad I started doing it.
 

DaveB

Grenadier Owner
Local time
4:12 AM
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
7,782
Reaction score
15,717
Location
Toogoom, Fraser Coast Queensland
I reached out directly to IA on this and after collecting information from me they did a variety of "make the customer give up" stalling. After continuing to press, this is the response they ended with:
"Looking into your request further with our team, the information provided by the dealership on the service report you have provided is all we can recommend at this time as there are no fixes available."

My dealer circled back with them after this and now Ineos is going to have them replace my pump once all the seals and fluids are received at my dealer. We'll see what that does.

Still no recognition from IA that this is a problem.

Dealers can be a pain in the ass, but I made sure it was an IA problem before I called them out. And if the shame campaign is working, then I can only say I'm glad I started doing it.
I bet the dealer had never spoken with them about it.
Once you spoke with Ineos there was action.
I have heard of a few people with steering pump issues but not an endemic problem.
As Ineos will claim it back on the manufacturer there is really no reason for them to cover it up.
 

Lars

Grenadier Owner
Local time
10:12 AM
Joined
May 19, 2022
Messages
120
Reaction score
191
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
I bet the dealer had never spoken with them about it.
Once you spoke with Ineos there was action.
I have heard of a few people with steering pump issues but not an endemic problem.
As Ineos will claim it back on the manufacturer there is really no reason for them to cover it up.
There's plenty of reason for Ineos not to act. It does cost them money for warranty work, and admitting a problem opens it up to everyone who thinks the PS pump is making noise. I don't get the "Don't blame Ineos, Blame the dealer" stance. There are so many posts on this forum where people have contacted Ineos directly (and their dealer) and had various responses, sometimes contradictory. Unfortunately, the only way to solve a problem is to keep pushing as IdahoGrenadier has. This is not unique to the auto industry either.
While I'm on a tear, the other thing I don't get are the posts that essentially say "I don't have that problem, so it must be you just complaining"
 

DaveB

Grenadier Owner
Local time
4:12 AM
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
7,782
Reaction score
15,717
Location
Toogoom, Fraser Coast Queensland
There's plenty of reason for Ineos not to act. It does cost them money for warranty work, and admitting a problem opens it up to everyone who thinks the PS pump is making noise. I don't get the "Don't blame Ineos, Blame the dealer" stance. There are so many posts on this forum where people have contacted Ineos directly (and their dealer) and had various responses, sometimes contradictory. Unfortunately, the only way to solve a problem is to keep pushing as IdahoGrenadier has. This is not unique to the auto industry either.
While I'm on a tear, the other thing I don't get are the posts that essentially say "I don't have that problem, so it must be you just complaining"
Until recently Ineos have been selling the vehicle basically by word of mouth between enthusiasts and open/drive days.
In most of the world the purchase is done direct with Ineos and not through a dealer.

The US model has been different and more traditional.

It should therefore be in Ineos interest to fix any problems.
We all know that fixes have been slow in coming, and communication has been poor, but generally they have acknowledged problems.

Justin Hocevar in his interview series with Robert Pepper was very open and candid.

In Australia we have had people saying initially that their dealer couldn't get any information out of Ineos regarding delivery of their vehicles, when they were leaving the factory etc.
For a large number of us we had all this information and were posting on here tracking our vehicles on the actual ships.

It seemed strange at the time that Ineos would tell some people exactly what wa happening and others were in the dark.

There seemed to be a potential issue with the more traditional car dealers mainly.
This is understandable as they would not usually pass on that kind of information to buyers of their main brands.
At best they may say it is due into the country in September

Many early owners had a lot of problems and these were slow to be fixed.
Most of these issues were then corrected on future deliveries.

When people say "I don't have that problem" it is merely to show that the problem isn't across 100% or even 50% of the vehicles, and acknowledging that it is in fact a problem with that particular vehicle, or group of vehicles.

In the early stages, and still occasionally, we had people posting the emails and mobile numbers of senior global Ineos people and telling everyone to email and call them.
Then surprise surprise the same people started complaining they were getting no response.

One of the people was the Global head of service (I think that was his title) and could you imagine what would happen if he woke up to 1,000 missed calls and 1,000 unread emails.
Is he going to respond to them or will he be forced to change his mobile number and email address?

The steering has been a classic example.
A lot of people have been complaining that it is dangerous, it will cause crashes
Ineos need to fix it.

Then you find out they have either never driven one, or have driven it for less than an hour.

One extremely bombastic person on Facebook was carrying on that Ineos should recall all vehicles and change them to rack & pinion steering like all other vehicles.
when it was explained to him that it was not possible to use that on a live axle 4WD he then demanded that Ineos go to an independent front end.

Lastly
The very title of this thread starts with "Don't buy a Grenadier" and then it should read "because some people have had steering pump and HVAC issues"
 

IdahoGrenadier

Grenadier Owner
Local time
11:12 AM
Joined
May 15, 2024
Messages
50
Reaction score
79
Location
Boise, ID, USA
Until recently Ineos have been selling the vehicle basically by word of mouth between enthusiasts and open/drive days.
In most of the world the purchase is done direct with Ineos and not through a dealer.

The US model has been different and more traditional.

It should therefore be in Ineos interest to fix any problems.
We all know that fixes have been slow in coming, and communication has been poor, but generally they have acknowledged problems.

Justin Hocevar in his interview series with Robert Pepper was very open and candid.

In Australia we have had people saying initially that their dealer couldn't get any information out of Ineos regarding delivery of their vehicles, when they were leaving the factory etc.
For a large number of us we had all this information and were posting on here tracking our vehicles on the actual ships.

It seemed strange at the time that Ineos would tell some people exactly what wa happening and others were in the dark.

There seemed to be a potential issue with the more traditional car dealers mainly.
This is understandable as they would not usually pass on that kind of information to buyers of their main brands.
At best they may say it is due into the country in September

Many early owners had a lot of problems and these were slow to be fixed.
Most of these issues were then corrected on future deliveries.

When people say "I don't have that problem" it is merely to show that the problem isn't across 100% or even 50% of the vehicles, and acknowledging that it is in fact a problem with that particular vehicle, or group of vehicles.

In the early stages, and still occasionally, we had people posting the emails and mobile numbers of senior global Ineos people and telling everyone to email and call them.
Then surprise surprise the same people started complaining they were getting no response.

One of the people was the Global head of service (I think that was his title) and could you imagine what would happen if he woke up to 1,000 missed calls and 1,000 unread emails.
Is he going to respond to them or will he be forced to change his mobile number and email address?

The steering has been a classic example.
A lot of people have been complaining that it is dangerous, it will cause crashes
Ineos need to fix it.

Then you find out they have either never driven one, or have driven it for less than an hour.

One extremely bombastic person on Facebook was carrying on that Ineos should recall all vehicles and change them to rack & pinion steering like all other vehicles.
when it was explained to him that it was not possible to use that on a live axle 4WD he then demanded that Ineos go to an independent front end.

Lastly
The very title of this thread starts with "Don't buy a Grenadier" and then it should read "because some people have had steering pump and HVAC issues"
I agree with just about everything you say here except the conclusion. Because if you read my first post, the second half of the statement is not because some people have had steering pump and HVAC issues. I actually said because the company's response to those of us who have had problems does not give confidence that they will stand behind the product as other problems develop.
 
Local time
1:12 PM
Joined
Apr 28, 2023
Messages
1,132
Reaction score
970
Location
Pittsburgh
I'm pretty confident it was noticed and just accepted, all the PTO2 trucks had very loud PS pumps and we all learned to just accept it as the norm
Are you referring to the pre production trucks that were there just to test drive on a course at 5mph, and we were told missing parts and other oddities would naturally be rectified by production time?
 
Back
Top Bottom