The Grenadier Forum
Register Now for enhanced site access.
INEOS Agents, Dealers or Commercial vendors please contact admin@theineosforum.com for a commercial account.

Sold after 11 months of ownership. My final post and final thoughts.

Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
Apr 28, 2023
Messages
1,186
Reaction score
1,024
Location
Pittsburgh
I bought it used, so it was about a decade old. Want to talk about deprecitiation... those big Lux SUVs take major hits the first few years, then they keep their value fairly well. THey have inherent value, it's just they luxury parts that I think depreciate fast.
I'm more thinking if one gives a starving man porridge, He'll think its beef consume from a Michelin 4 star.
 

MileHigh

That Guy
Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
Aug 4, 2022
Messages
803
Reaction score
909
Location
Colorado
I'm more thinking if one gives a starving man porridge, He'll think its beef consume from a Michelin 4 star.
Not sure what you mean? That I was 'starving' in an Escalade? That thing was gangster, literally. Greatest way to knock down highway miles ever. 22 inch rims with almost racing slicks as standard that seemed to last 10k miles was a PITA.
 

BD1

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
1:56 PM
Joined
Oct 2, 2022
Messages
345
Reaction score
892
Location
Illinois
I think the larger annoyance with the visor is that it doesn't slide out to extend leaving large gaps uncovered (my 99 LC 100 has dual visors which is brilliant), and when rotated to the side window, it is absolutely useless, covering about an inch of window. It is due to the shape of the roof angling the visor upward. They should have installed a leveling spacer to resolve this issue.

Surprised not any comments about the useless visors. Lol. Nowhere near a deal breaker.
This is why I like the owl visors. Not cheap but excellent product.
 

DaveB

Grenadier Owner
Local time
5:56 AM
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
7,868
Reaction score
15,897
Location
Toogoom, Fraser Coast Queensland
I think the larger annoyance with the visor is that it doesn't slide out to extend leaving large gaps uncovered (my 99 LC 100 has dual visors which is brilliant), and when rotated to the side window, it is absolutely useless, covering about an inch of window. It is due to the shape of the roof angling the visor upward. They should have installed a leveling spacer to resolve this issue.

Surprised not any comments about the useless visors. Lol. Nowhere near a deal breaker.
VTX Pro Ceramic window tint on the Safari windows and the two front windows and no problem with heat or glare.
Factory heat resistant dark glass for the rest.
Solves all the problems except out the windscreen and good quality sunglasses solves that.
1736291605782.png
1736291630464.png
 

DaveB

Grenadier Owner
Local time
5:56 AM
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
7,868
Reaction score
15,897
Location
Toogoom, Fraser Coast Queensland
There are cultural differences at play here, this complaint is almost exclusively coming from US customers. One might suggest that the ladies in the US place a higher priority on their cosmetic appearance when out with their partners than other parts of the new world.
I don't know, I have seen a lot of women here that put it on with a spray gun and a brickies trowel.
View: https://www.tiktok.com/@provinceshana/video/7337222140682439941?lang=en
 
Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
Oct 17, 2024
Messages
14
Reaction score
27
Location
USA
There are cultural differences at play here, this complaint is almost exclusively coming from US customers. One might suggest that the ladies in the US place a higher priority on their cosmetic appearance when out with their partners than other parts of the new world.
Of course - people in the USA and Canada tend to equate money with things like exclusivity, luxury, and quality (in that order). So to most Americans, spending USD 90k on a vehicle must be a "luxury" type vehicle, it must impress at the strip mall. Germans drop the same amount of money on a Mercedes E350 and to them it's what Americans would consider a Ford Taurus. I am not bashing anyone here, but how people value their money or categorize expectations based on consumables group varies widely.


What are you insinuating about the Mrs. B'eezy?
That she also expects illuminated visor mirrors on your 80k John Deere tractor.
 
Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
Apr 28, 2023
Messages
1,186
Reaction score
1,024
Location
Pittsburgh
Not sure what you mean? That I was 'starving' in an Escalade? That thing was gangster, literally. Greatest way to knock down highway miles ever. 22 inch rims with almost racing slicks as standard that seemed to last 10k miles was a PITA.
No, more that you finally got a taste of owning an actual 4x4, but because you've suffered with that bloated station wagon, it's gonna seem like the best 4x4 ever.
 
Local time
12:56 PM
Joined
Sep 12, 2024
Messages
338
Reaction score
252
Location
Denver, Co
I think the larger annoyance with the visor is that it doesn't slide out to extend leaving large gaps uncovered (my 99 LC 100 has dual visors which is brilliant), and when rotated to the side window, it is absolutely useless, covering about an inch of window. It is due to the shape of the roof angling the visor upward. They should have installed a leveling spacer to resolve this issue.

Surprised not any comments about the useless visors. Lol. Nowhere near a deal breaker.
Hmm I have my seat cranked up to max height. When I am driving my head is like above the top of the side window. lol
 

DaveB

Grenadier Owner
Local time
5:56 AM
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
7,868
Reaction score
15,897
Location
Toogoom, Fraser Coast Queensland
Of course - people in the USA and Canada tend to equate money with things like exclusivity, luxury, and quality (in that order). So to most Americans, spending USD 90k on a vehicle must be a "luxury" type vehicle, it must impress at the strip mall. Germans drop the same amount of money on a Mercedes E350 and to them it's what Americans would consider a Ford Taurus. I am not bashing anyone here, but how people value their money or categorize expectations based on consumables group varies widely.



That she also expects illuminated visor mirrors on your 80k John Deere tractor.
In Australia some of the highest paid industries is in the mines and tradies get paid extremely well.
Here is a current job for an electrician on a 2:1 FIFO(Fly In Fly Out) roster
The work is 14 days on 10-12 hour a day then 7 days off.
Accomodation, meals etc are all provided on site and are very good quality.
Gyms, pools etc
$6,000 a week is plus 12.5% super minimum plus any other site allowances
This is the type of person who would probably be happy to buy a 70 series Toyota and spend another $100,000 on doing it up.
Probably also own a boat.
They aren't looking for exclusivity or luxury. Probably the opposite.
Hard to compare against the other guys if you have something completely different.
You want the same but better.
Also customers for the Grenadier or more likely the Quartermaster Cab Chassis

1736303783306.png
 

CrazyOldMan

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
1:56 PM
Joined
Mar 13, 2024
Messages
736
Reaction score
755
Location
Wisconsin, USA
In Australia some of the highest paid industries is in the mines and tradies get paid extremely well.
Here is a current job for an electrician on a 2:1 FIFO(Fly In Fly Out) roster
The work is 14 days on 10-12 hour a day then 7 days off.
Accomodation, meals etc are all provided on site and are very good quality.
Gyms, pools etc
$6,000 a week is plus 12.5% super minimum plus any other site allowances
This is the type of person who would probably be happy to buy a 70 series Toyota and spend another $100,000 on doing it up.
Probably also own a boat.
They aren't looking for exclusivity or luxury. Probably the opposite.
Hard to compare against the other guys if you have something completely different.
You want the same but better.
Also customers for the Grenadier or more likely the Quartermaster Cab Chassis

View attachment 7883737
It’s an interesting question - far from the original topic, but one that I wonder about - who are the buyers in different markets? The profile you paint, @DaveB, also exists in the US - and they are also spending $100K+ on their trucks, but I don’t think the Grenadier. There is no romantic image of the old Defender. There is no respect (or acceptance) of a BMW engine. The British design and Hambach manufacturing are not valued. They are looking for big, imposing, with high payload and towing capacity and 8 under the hood. Think more along the lines of a GMC 2500/3500 Sierra Heavy Duty or Ford F350 Super Duty. If they off-road, think more along the lines of a Rubicon on 37’s - a rock crawler config - but just as likely they take that big truck and tow out their SxS. I think you (rather politely) point out that the US buyers seem to have the highest expectations from a luxury perspective- we whine a lot about the steering pump noise, SW lags and ADAS alerts, seat comfort, AC / fan noise, etc. Your observation of the different expectations is spot on. But as much as I hate to say it, if the US is the biggest market, if Ineos wants to have long-term prospects, they’ve got to pay attention to those concerns and address them - or they’ll have a lot more people like the OP. Even those GM 2500’s are luxury barges.
 

Tom D

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
7:56 PM
Joined
Jun 3, 2022
Messages
1,034
Reaction score
2,812
Location
Berwickshire
I think most of the issues in the OP are fairly common, some of which I have experienced myself. How happy you are with your vehicle depends on your original expectations.
For me it has always been a compromise.
There is no other vehicle available in the UK that suits my needs, there really isn’t. But the G is not perfect, far from it. I am happy to put up with the failures as there are other things that I like about the G that other vehicles don't have. I say ‘happy’, I mean I’ll put up with minor foibles…

If my car lets me down mechanically, it will be a different story but so far any issues that I have had have been minor annoyances.

I am getting increasingly pissed off with the lack of a workshop manual though. And that fact that any disconnection of the battery WILL result in error codes that only the dealer can reset.

I remember posting on here about 2 years ago that if you are coming from a LR Disco or BMW X5 and expecting the same you will be disappointed. If you are coming from an old defender you will be much happier.

If the Grenadier was electronics (computer) free it would be a much better car. But it is impossible to build such a thing these days so it is what it is.
 
Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
May 25, 2022
Messages
55
Reaction score
51
If the Grenadier was electronics (computer) free it would be a much better car. But it is impossible to build such a thing these days so it is what it is.
Sure, but the electronics that do exist could have been implemented far better. IMO its far less a case of 'computers == bad' and more like 'Ineos and their subcontractors did a poor job implementing the cars electronics overall'. It's frustrating to me because the electronics in the Grenadier are relatively rudimentary implementations of solved problems. It's not like Ineos is pushing the automotive frontier with them like LR does with it's electronic terrain response system, Porsche with its performance tuning, Tesla with autonomous driving, etc.

As a software engineer, one of the most baffling decisions made was to release without any way for customers to update software (OTA or otherwise) especially given the state of the dealer network. Again, this is another solved problem in the automotive world. I mean, you put out a v1.0 to the world and don't give yourself a way to fix critical issues quickly? The hubris. I also take some issue with the pace (ie lack therof) of said updates, but if they did subcontract out to the lowest bidder it tracks.

I don't like to give any corporation a pass when they drop the ball even a little. The software/electronic weirdness/quirkyness is overall a minor annoyance for me given the rudimentary feature set, but its enough of one to not just handwave away and imo deserves criticism.
 
Last edited:

Tom D

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
7:56 PM
Joined
Jun 3, 2022
Messages
1,034
Reaction score
2,812
Location
Berwickshire
Sure, but the electronics that do exist could have been implemented far better. IMO its far less a case of 'computers == bad' and more like 'Ineos and their subcontractors did a poor job implementing the cars electronics overall'. It's frustrating to me because the electronics in the Grenadier are relatively rudimentary implementations of solved problems. It's not like Ineos is pushing the automotive frontier with them like LR does with it's electronic terrain response system, Porsche with its performance tuning, Tesla with autonomous driving, etc.

As a software engineer, one of the most baffling decisions made was to release without any way for customers to update software (OTA or otherwise) especially given the state of the dealer network. Again, this is another solved problem in the automotive world. I mean, you put out a v1.0 to the world and don't give yourself a way to fix critical issues quickly? The hubris. I also take some issue with the pace (ie lack therof) of said updates, but if they did subcontract out to the lowest bidder it tracks.

I don't like to give any corporation a pass when they drop the ball even a little. The software/electronic weirdness/quirkyness is overall a minor annoyance for me given the rudimentary feature set, but its enough of one to not just handwave away and imo deserves criticism.
I agree. The electronics and lack of customer serviceability are my two main gripes.
 

CrazyOldMan

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
1:56 PM
Joined
Mar 13, 2024
Messages
736
Reaction score
755
Location
Wisconsin, USA
I can't believe I spent all this money and the driver's seat doesn't have a testicuzzi.
Maybe Scheel-Mann makes an aftermarket seat with that option??? In all seriousness, I think many of us recognize the OP had a lot of legitimate issues/concerns, and I really appreciate the deliberate way they framed it all out. It seems the difference between buyers who stay and those who go is less about the issues, themselves, and a little more about how the reality matches up with expectations. Certain expectations (eg service manual, etc) are universal, and all of us are critical about that. Other expectations (eg steering noise level), it depends who you ask. Most of us are incurable romantics and contrarians - and a little nuts. For some of us, what the Grenadier delivers itches that scratch - for others, it’s not enough.
 

MileHigh

That Guy
Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
Aug 4, 2022
Messages
803
Reaction score
909
Location
Colorado
No, more that you finally got a taste of owning an actual 4x4, but because you've suffered with that bloated station wagon, it's gonna seem like the best 4x4 ever.
That was just my most recent vehicle and the reason why I wanted to go with something like the Grenadier. But I’ve also had 1990s Jeep Cherokee’s and Isuzu troopers, a couple of grand Cherokee’s from 25 years ago, two Jeep wranglers, and a Toyota four Runner. Also, Escalade‘s and Tahoe’s are not bloated up wagons, they are actually tarted up pick up trucks. I’m far from an expert on 4 x 4‘s, but I definitely have some good points of reference.
 

Jackattack13

Grenadier Owner
Local time
11:56 AM
Joined
Jan 18, 2024
Messages
312
Reaction score
443
Location
Carlsbad, CA, USA
Sure, but the electronics that do exist could have been implemented far better. IMO its far less a case of 'computers == bad' and more like 'Ineos and their subcontractors did a poor job implementing the cars electronics overall'. It's frustrating to me because the electronics in the Grenadier are relatively rudimentary implementations of solved problems. It's not like Ineos is pushing the automotive frontier with them like LR does with it's electronic terrain response system, Porsche with its performance tuning, Tesla with autonomous driving, etc.

As a software engineer, one of the most baffling decisions made was to release without any way for customers to update software (OTA or otherwise) especially given the state of the dealer network. Again, this is another solved problem in the automotive world. I mean, you put out a v1.0 to the world and don't give yourself a way to fix critical issues quickly? The hubris. I also take some issue with the pace (ie lack therof) of said updates, but if they did subcontract out to the lowest bidder it tracks.

I don't like to give any corporation a pass when they drop the ball even a little. The software/electronic weirdness/quirkyness is overall a minor annoyance for me given the rudimentary feature set, but its enough of one to not just handwave away and imo deserves criticism.
You stated this perfectly! Their solutions were rudimentary at best. Enough to get the job done, but not in a good way. LOL. And the false promises of updates, etc. is maddening itself.

The lack of manual and ability to reset service reminders is damn near a deal breaker itself for those that like to work on their own cars, live too far from a dealer for basic maintenance like oil changes and gear oil, or travel to remote areas where no dealer network exists. I fell victim to "Its on its way." statements from the dealer. All of which have yet to materialize almost a year after purchasing.
 

MileHigh

That Guy
Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
Aug 4, 2022
Messages
803
Reaction score
909
Location
Colorado
It’s an interesting question - far from the original topic, but one that I wonder about - who are the buyers in different markets? The profile you paint, @DaveB, also exists in the US - and they are also spending $100K+ on their trucks, but I don’t think the Grenadier. There is no romantic image of the old Defender. There is no respect (or acceptance) of a BMW engine. The British design and Hambach manufacturing are not valued. They are looking for big, imposing, with high payload and towing capacity and 8 under the hood. Think more along the lines of a GMC 2500/3500 Sierra Heavy Duty or Ford F350 Super Duty. If they off-road, think more along the lines of a Rubicon on 37’s - a rock crawler config - but just as likely they take that big truck and tow out their SxS. I think you (rather politely) point out that the US buyers seem to have the highest expectations from a luxury perspective- we whine a lot about the steering pump noise, SW lags and ADAS alerts, seat comfort, AC / fan noise, etc. Your observation of the different expectations is spot on. But as much as I hate to say it, if the US is the biggest market, if Ineos wants to have long-term prospects, they’ve got to pay attention to those concerns and address them - or they’ll have a lot more people like the OP. Even those GM 2500’s are luxury barges.
I think I can distill you comment down to that the IG, is at its core, an Overlanding vehicle, and we don't have a history here in the US with vehicles for that, in this form. Pickups with Campers in the bed, small pop-up trailers, small truck based RVs, and now sprinter and other vans. Sure there are 4x4s with rooftop tents, but our 4x4s mostly either rock-crawling/mud-running focused or mall crawlers. I do think that there is an upsurge in overlanding here, and the IG may be in the perfect spot to capitalize on it.

I can't believe I spent all this money and the driver's seat doesn't have a testicuzzi.
Better yet, ala "The Fifth Element"
1736355661409.png
 
Back
Top Bottom