The Grenadier Forum

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to contribute to the community by adding your own topics, posts, and connect with other members through your own private inbox! INEOS Agents, Dealers or Commercial vendors please contact admin@theineosforum.com for a commercial account.

Petrol/Gas US Oil for B58 Engines

Not much really. The ethanol free gas tends to be on lower octane. I'm experimenting now with regular gas to see what % drop I see in mpg. I do notice a slight performance decrease but in the end the numbers will tell.
The ethanol free I'm using is 90. And on road trips I've been using octane boost and see good increases in MPG, cause I'm usually trying to minimize stopping to every 3-3.5 hours.
 
The ethanol free I'm using is 90. And on road trips I've been using octane boost and see good increases in MPG, cause I'm usually trying to minimize stopping to every 3-3.5 hours.
Wow I only have the Buckees 87 octane ethanol free. But doesn't mess with the oil really. What kind of mpg are you at now? But to answer your question you can use any LL01 and LL04 oil. LL04 is actually a little better of a spec. It's low SAPS and better for direct injected motors. It wasn't specced for gas due to US regulations. EPA wanted lower ZDDP numbers so it was limited with gas motors but diesel were exempt. It's why in Europe they run LL04 but in the US they did LL01. Also had to do with sulfur levels but now the US fuels are perfectly fine to run LL04 oil. So I've been doing QS Euro 5w40 which definitely runs smoother than the 0w20. Pennzoil Platinum Euro is a 5w30 that's LL04. Hard to argue with the QS price. I change every 5k miles and filter every 10. I plan on keeping my guy forever and I'm also running a tune. I'll probably retire with this guy in 20yrs lol.
 
Wow I only have the Buckees 87 octane ethanol free. But doesn't mess with the oil really. What kind of mpg are you at now? But to answer your question you can use any LL01 and LL04 oil. LL04 is actually a little better of a spec. It's low SAPS and better for direct injected motors. It wasn't specced for gas due to US regulations. EPA wanted lower ZDDP numbers so it was limited with gas motors but diesel were exempt. It's why in Europe they run LL04 but in the US they did LL01. Also had to do with sulfur levels but now the US fuels are perfectly fine to run LL04 oil. So I've been doing QS Euro 5w40 which definitely runs smoother than the 0w20. Pennzoil Platinum Euro is a 5w30 that's LL04. Hard to argue with the QS price. I change every 5k miles and filter every 10. I plan on keeping my guy forever and I'm also running a tune. I'll probably retire with this guy in 20yrs lol.
You’re changing 100 bucks in oil on a 1/2 lifecycle, but you’re saving the soaked 10 dollar filter, that presumably is doing its job to clean the oil you want to get rid of.

Is there a logic behind that? I’ve never seen that on any type of industrial engine PM’s, and lord knows they try to nickel and dime that shit.
 
You’re changing 100 bucks in oil on a 1/2 lifecycle, but you’re saving the soaked 10 dollar filter, that presumably is doing its job to clean the oil you want to get rid of.

Is there a logic behind that? I’ve never seen that on any type of industrial engine PM’s, and lord knows they try to nickel and dime that shit.
The manual says 12k intervals and BMW use to say 16k but backed it down to 12k. A filter simply filters. The oil is what's doing the job of lubricating and fighting off elements. Longer drain intervals are kind of the opposite direction things are going with newer engines. They're starting to run lighter oil and tighter tolerances so pretty much everyone says if you want it to last you take your factory recommendation and cut it in half. My personal reasons for doing 5k miles is because it's an easy number to remember. When I'm about to hit 20k I know it's time to change. I could take it to 7.5k but don't really want to. I also drive it hard, run a tune, and have larger/heavier tires. I've done a VOA (virgin oil analysis) on my oil I've been using (Quaker State Euro) and have done multiple UOA to track the oil. It's a great oil and $22.50 at walmart for 5L. After taking the oil filters apart there was no reason to replace them at 5k. Even at 10k it was perfectly fine. The people that have seen the filters "deteriorate" is because they pull it off incorrectly so rip it up as they twist it off. They don't fail while in their housing.

I've went every other time because there wasn't any need for the filter. There isn't breakdown like in oil and this filter was a PIA to get out. I had the same setup on my 2017 LR Discovery TD6 and the only real mechanical issues I ever had was the air suspension pump going out and the housing over the filter fail because it's made of plastic and easier to strip. There's no reason to remove it at 5k miles and I don't want to fight to get in there and remove the housing anymore than I have to. I REALLY REALLY wish it had just been a metal screw on filter. But filters are for contaminants and oil is for protection. UOA's tell me if one or the other is failing or trending and really a filter doesn't do much. If you do frequent changes and keep the engine clean a filter could last a very long time. Mobile one and others have filter they say are good for 20k miles. Anyway if doing reduced oil change intervals it's common practice to do the filter every other change.

I've switched to FCPeuro and ordered Redline 5w30 oil through them. Many say it's the best oil there is for it's purpose. Since it's FCP and it's free replacements it will cost me about $18 a change. I did include the filter on the order so maybe I'll start doing it every change.

Here's a good video with the lead engineer of the Nissan GTR's badass engine and his views on oil change.

Here's another good one. I like watching his channel.

 
1) Why would you use Quaker State Euro in your Grenadier? It does not meet the specs for the Grenadier (per manual 0-20W, ACEA C2, BMW LL 17FE) and doing so may not cause your engine to blow up but it could jeopardize your warranty.

2) How do you know your oil filter is ok. A properly functioning filter will remove particles too small for the human eye to see. Do you do oil analysis in every change? (BTW, I think your 5k interval is a good investment.)



 
The manual says 12k intervals and BMW use to say 16k but backed it down to 12k. A filter simply filters. The oil is what's doing the job of lubricating and fighting off elements. Longer drain intervals are kind of the opposite direction things are going with newer engines. They're starting to run lighter oil and tighter tolerances so pretty much everyone says if you want it to last you take your factory recommendation and cut it in half. My personal reasons for doing 5k miles is because it's an easy number to remember. When I'm about to hit 20k I know it's time to change. I could take it to 7.5k but don't really want to. I also drive it hard, run a tune, and have larger/heavier tires. I've done a VOA (virgin oil analysis) on my oil I've been using (Quaker State Euro) and have done multiple UOA to track the oil. It's a great oil and $22.50 at walmart for 5L. After taking the oil filters apart there was no reason to replace them at 5k. Even at 10k it was perfectly fine. The people that have seen the filters "deteriorate" is because they pull it off incorrectly so rip it up as they twist it off. They don't fail while in their housing.

I've went every other time because there wasn't any need for the filter. There isn't breakdown like in oil and this filter was a PIA to get out. I had the same setup on my 2017 LR Discovery TD6 and the only real mechanical issues I ever had was the air suspension pump going out and the housing over the filter fail because it's made of plastic and easier to strip. There's no reason to remove it at 5k miles and I don't want to fight to get in there and remove the housing anymore than I have to. I REALLY REALLY wish it had just been a metal screw on filter. But filters are for contaminants and oil is for protection. UOA's tell me if one or the other is failing or trending and really a filter doesn't do much. If you do frequent changes and keep the engine clean a filter could last a very long time. Mobile one and others have filter they say are good for 20k miles. Anyway if doing reduced oil change intervals it's common practice to do the filter every other change.

I've switched to FCPeuro and ordered Redline 5w30 oil through them. Many say it's the best oil there is for it's purpose. Since it's FCP and it's free replacements it will cost me about $18 a change. I did include the filter on the order so maybe I'll start doing it every change.

Here's a good video with the lead engineer of the Nissan GTR's badass engine and his views on oil change.

Here's another good one. I like watching his channel.

I don't care about any of that. It's a diatribe about nothing to do with the logic I'm questioning.

You are changing the oil at 1/2 life cycle. The filter is no better than than the oil. You can do the filter while the oil is dribbling out, and its basically a free item. THERE IS NO LOGIC to keeping a filter clogged with the oil you think needs changing when its a no cost operation.
 
1) Why would you use Quaker State Euro in your Grenadier? It does not meet the specs for the Grenadier (per manual 0-20W, ACEA C2, BMW LL 17FE) and doing so may not cause your engine to blow up but it could jeopardize your warranty.

2) How do you know your oil filter is ok. A properly functioning filter will remove particles too small for the human eye to see. Do you do oil analysis in every change? (BTW, I think your 5k interval is a good investment.)



Read the initial post here but the only reason LL17FE exists is because of US CAFE laws and not because it's what's best. BMW released a white paper study and showed they gained a 3% increase in mpg by going to the lighter oil. They didn't show it protected anything better. Their goal is to get you to end of warranty. I do oil analysis on my changes to see what's trending and how things are going.

The engine was designed and specced with LL01/LL04 and I plan on keeping it forever so I go with oil with higher protection standards. They didn't go with the new standard until the 2018 year model for CAFE reason's and even then the manual still states you can use LL01.

bmw oil.PNG
 
Last edited:
I don't care about any of that. It's a diatribe about nothing to do with the logic I'm questioning.

You are changing the oil at 1/2 life cycle. The filter is no better than than the oil. You can do the filter while the oil is dribbling out, and its basically a free item. THERE IS NO LOGIC to keeping a filter clogged with the oil you think needs changing when its a no cost operation.
I answered this directly. The factory oil and filter change recommendation is 12k miles. The filter only filters. The oil can break down due to moisture, heat, etc. The filter isn't clogged and doesn't need the changing. The oil's HTHS however starts to lower and it starts to lose it's effectiveness after 5k miles. Recommended change interval based on UOA is 7.5k but I'd rather just do it at 5k miles to keep it simple on me. It's very common when doing shorter oil change intervals to do the filter every other change. The logic being it's still completely effective even at the 10k interval so no reason to change it at 5k miles. The oil however is degrading. There's also the point that I don't want to F'k with it. It's difficult to get to and I don't want to remove the plastic housing anymore than I have to. It's a poor design and prone to failure.

It is completely possible to have oil completely junked and not have contaminants. I've never felt the filter was clogged with anything. I change it because it's fine at 10k miles but ready to be changed.
 
Read the initial post here but the only reason LL17FE exists is because of US CAFE laws and not because it's what's best. BMW released a white paper study and showed they gained a 3% increase in mpg by going to the lighter oil. They didn't show it protected anything better. Their goal is to get you to end of warranty. I do oil analysis on my changes to see what's trending and how things are going.

The engine was designed and specced with LL01/LL04 and I plan on keeping it forever so I go with oil with higher protection standards. They didn't go with the new standard until the 2018 year model for CAFE reason's and even then the manual still states you can use LL01.

View attachment 7887017
OK… so you are not running it in a Grenadier and that warranty would not be applicable. Is that correct?
 
Read the initial post here but the only reason LL17FE exists is because of US CAFE laws and not because it's what's best.
Then why doesn't Ineos spec different oil for the Grenadier outside the US?

FWIW, I'm no oil expert, but I did see this video from those Royalty Auto Service guys the other day. It seems kind of ridiculous to me to claim this is a 10k mile interval:
View: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/dXSHfN-nYiY
 
Then why doesn't Ineos spec different oil for the Grenadier outside the US?

FWIW, I'm no oil expert, but I did see this video from those Royalty Auto Service guys the other day. It seems kind of ridiculous to me to claim this is a 10k mile interval:
View: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/dXSHfN-nYiY
I don't know why Ineos doesn't. I doubt they have any testing or anything they simply buy the engine from BMW with it's own warranties and restrictions attached. But because of these lighter oils most shops are starting to roll back their interval recommendations. I see it as preventative maintenance. The 0w20's sheer resistance is pretty low and over time will start to gum up. I can't imagine doing 12k intervals on that engine with 6000lbs behind it. The additive packages are so light that it simply can't be as robust. The NOAK of a 20 grade vs a 30/40 grade alone means there's going to be burn-off and a change in it's chemistry. Even Redline 0w20 is like 9% burn off where the 5w30 is 5%. Based on UOA's most oils are great until 6k, pretty good at 7.5k, then start to fall off from there. There's acceptable wear limits and even oil burn limits. From BMW: "For BMW spark-ignition and diesel engines, the maximum permissible engine oil consumption is 0.7 l/1000 km". That's 1 quart per 842.254 miles. The 0w20 oils, industry wide, have made seals and consumptions a real issue. I ran the 0w20 to start and did my UOAs with it then went to Pennzoil Euro L (ll04) and QS Euro and it's been super happy. Much smoother. Weights are an American thing. HTHS is what matters and the B58 was designed with a HTHS range of 3.5-4.1. 0w20 is generally anywhere from 2.4-3.1 (I think, old memory) and there's no way that holds up for 12k miles like it should. Will it go 60k miles, sure. Will it go 500k miles, highly doubtful. I'm not worried about making it to the end of warranty. That's two years from now. It's making it for the next 20+yrs that I'm gunning for. Plus I run larger heavier tires and an engine tune. Just my personal preference. When this thread first started no one had any idea where to even get oil and there was very little info coming from anywhere. Things have had time to mature since. I think the 0w20 is fine for most people doing daily hops around town. It gets to operating temp quicker so initially offers better protection. I routinely am 100+ deg and drive it like I stole it (the tune really makes it that much more fun) so I've opted to stick with the higher HTHS oils. Going out to Moab or West Texas where it's 105+ and off roading where it's high rpm, high load. To me that's insanity on 0w20. I'd like to see a UOA of a 12k interval of someone in hard temps that's off roading or towing a lot.
 
I doubt they have any testing or anything they simply buy the engine from BMW with it's own warranties and restrictions attached.
This part isn't entirely correct. While the hardware is BMW, the DME tuning is completely bespoke, from what I was told it was performed directly through Bosch as the DME mapping doesn't mimic BMW's at all (this part has been confirmed by a US tuner who is attempting to decrypt/unlock the DME for tuning for some big power). Additionally, Ineos does have specific mileage expectations (without notable repairs/failures) for the entire drivetrain that is substantially longer than the warranty period. It was in an internal document, so I'm not comfortable stating the number specifically, but it was well beyond 100,000 miles; and well in excess of BMW's own lifecycle goal.
 
This part isn't entirely correct. While the hardware is BMW, the DME tuning is completely bespoke, from what I was told it was performed directly through Bosch as the DME mapping doesn't mimic BMW's at all (this part has been confirmed by a US tuner who is attempting to decrypt/unlock the DME for tuning for some big power). Additionally, Ineos does have specific mileage expectations (without notable repairs/failures) for the entire drivetrain that is substantially longer than the warranty period. It was in an internal document, so I'm not comfortable stating the number specifically, but it was well beyond 100,000 miles; and well in excess of BMW's own lifecycle goal.
Could be. I was just making an educated wish on his Q. I knew it was remapped with their specifics for lower power (higher reliability) and keeping the torque but they still have to be within BMW's operating specs unless they want to toss all the guarantees out the window.
 
Back
Top Bottom