[QUOTE username=NoGaBiker userid=8980684 postid=1332816855]
Quoting two out of a short list of 7 makes the absence of the other ones conspicuous so naturally I assumed you specifically meant those two. Thank you for clearing up the confusion. [/QUOTE][QUOTE username=NoGaBiker userid=8980684 postid=1332816855]
I agree wholeheartedly about the KO2 -- had one set in 315/70-17 on a Jeep and they were my least favorite tire out of 5 sets I had. I opted for the Cooper Discoverer RT on my L664 Landy and I like them very much. But... I have a set of 18" offroad wheels and tires (the Coopers) and I run my OEM Goodyear Wrangler Adventures (20") for 90% of my use, which is on road. I only mount the Coopers when I'm going for a serious off-road excursion. They are louder than the Goodyears (as expected) but not at all unacceptable. I find them to be the perfect compromise for my use, but if I couldn't have two sets of wheels/tires, I'd have an AT rather than an RT, at least on a new Defender, which is quiet and refined. On an older Defender or a Jeep or Bronco or Toyota Pickup or 4Runner Id opt for RTs because the trucks themselves are so (relatively) rough and noisy that a quieter tire isn't worth nearly as much as it is on a new LR/RR.[/QUOTE]
If I lived in a warm climate, I would probably take your approach, and run two sets of 'summer' tires - one for on-road use, and one specifically for off-road use. However, most people will not fall into this category. But if you
are running two sets of 'summer' tires, then the choice of tires really becomes quite simple:
buy a good set of on-road tires, and a good set of off-road tires. The challenge for people running one set of tires is finding a good compromise tire. How an individual uses their vehicle and how they prioritize their needs will shape this decision, and the best option will vary from person to person.
Winters are long here at 8,500 feet in the Rockies, so we run two sets of tires on all our vehicles: Nokian Hakkapeliitta for the winter, and BFG KO2s in the summer.
Since we rarely find ourselves in deep mud, I have yet to find a better all-around overland tire than the BFG KO2.
(1) It has a higher speed rating than most other tires in its class
(2) It is quiet on the highway, and handles well in the corners with its stout sidewall (we run the E-rated version)
(3) It is great at speed on dirt, gravel, and desert roads
(4) It is really good in the rocks, and provides all the traction we require for the rock-crawling we do (we don't go out looking to rock-crawl for 'sport' - i.e. we are not looking to do the hardest rock-climbs we can find). I've had punctured and slashed sidewalls with other tires, but - knock on wood - not with KO2s.
(5) Its great for our use in the sand (we tend to find ourselves on flattish sand, we are not looking to climb dunes)
(6) It is winter-rated, so it provides a little peace of mind if we miscalculate the timing of switching from summer to winter tires
Only negative in my experience: the KO2 is not a good mud tire
Like I said, everyone has different needs and intended uses for their vehicle, and this will be reflected in tire choice.
Check out this review if you are interested:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_4dTv_jJyLs