The Grenadier Forum
Register Now for enhanced site access.
INEOS Agents, Dealers or Commercial vendors please contact admin@theineosforum.com for a commercial account.

Green Hydrogen progress

bemax

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
12:44 AM
Joined
May 12, 2022
Messages
2,600
Reaction score
5,031
Location
Germany
It might work for long distances but if you need it within a certain range for your daily drive it still is not enough to convince the people to buy a hydrogen car.
But of course you are right. The trend is your friend
 

G-Man

Grenadier Owner
Local time
11:44 PM
Joined
May 19, 2022
Messages
326
Reaction score
646
Location
Aberdeen, Scotland
The problem with hydrogen is that it is such a tiny molecule it'll leak through just about anything that isn't a dense material (think along the lines of the helium balloons that you get for birthday parties that rapidly deflate) so you have to completely re-think what you know about gas plumbing and storage.

As an example, regular inexpensive elastomers are completely useless for seals/hoses and have to be substituted for metal crush seals and hard plumbing which are much more expensive to buy, install (properly!) and maintain. The hydrogen will also eat into a lot of solid materials that you'd normally use for storage tanks (including inexpensive metals) and make them brittle over time, making it a challenge to store and transport safely without spending big bucks. When you also consider that hydrogen systems will need a belt and braces approach to detecting/preventing leaks and mitigation to prevent fireball explosions in a crash it's a big jump from existing fuel technology. Ultimately it's a massively expensive option and until it's equally expensive to use DERV I think it's going to remain a bit of a novelty.
 

klarie

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
12:44 AM
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
1,064
Reaction score
2,297
Location
Rhine - Main Area / Germany
The problem with hydrogen is that it is such a tiny molecule it'll leak through just about anything that isn't a dense material (think along the lines of the helium balloons that you get for birthday parties that rapidly deflate) so you have to completely re-think what you know about gas plumbing and storage.

As an example, regular inexpensive elastomers are completely useless for seals/hoses and have to be substituted for metal crush seals and hard plumbing which are much more expensive to buy, install (properly!) and maintain. The hydrogen will also eat into a lot of solid materials that you'd normally use for storage tanks (including inexpensive metals) and make them brittle over time, making it a challenge to store and transport safely without spending big bucks. When you also consider that hydrogen systems will need a belt and braces approach to detecting/preventing leaks and mitigation to prevent fireball explosions in a crash it's a big jump from existing fuel technology. Ultimately it's a massively expensive option and until it's equally expensive to use DERV I think it's going to remain a bit of a novelty.
100% agreed that explains my worries and the reason I do not want frequent Challenger accident on the road. - Burning Teslas /similar already common.
That is the reason if I think of feasible FC solutions then its Methanol based.
Still the production is not very high - and efficiency could be better but way simpler in fule than BEV and H2FC ..
I wonder why this approach is not very much liked.. even if some former Audi developer has already an operational solution. range 600km plus... w/o restrictions
 
Local time
6:44 PM
Joined
Feb 4, 2022
Messages
149
Reaction score
324
Location
Texas, USA
One point that was presented in the Harry's Garage video with JCB H2. The use case for H2 in industrial applications and long haul train/trucking is a target because of the high runtime. We commute 1/2 hour each way in the morning and evening while the industrial equipment can be working 2 or 3 shifts straight through. Big difference in the amount of pollution savings, go after the big offenders first and then catch up with us little offenders.
 
Back
Top Bottom