The Grenadier Forum
Register Now for enhanced site access.
INEOS Agents, Dealers or Commercial vendors please contact admin@theineosforum.com for a commercial account.

Grenadier almost killed me (or/and someone else)

alexandruast

Grenadier Owner
Local time
9:48 AM
Joined
Apr 2, 2024
Messages
89
Reaction score
195
Location
Romania
I had a very scary moment with my IG a few days ago.
I decided to write about it, because I feel that Ineos doesn't care about Grenadier owners, whatsoever.
More on that, later. Now, the incident:
It was an early cold morning, driving on a very busy national road (Romania, DN1). I was just hitting the road, so I pressed the driver seat heating button to warm up a bit. After a few seconds and some dings and dangs, the telltale screen was lit like a Christmas tree, with errors on all major systems - steering, gearbox, abs, esc, brakes, hydraulics, engine. I continued to drive, because the car was driving normally and I was being used to the IG's bugs and quirks. While driving, I called the local dealership to investigate, because the last time I drove the IG was back from the dealership after the service interval (software update, fluids and filters) - I thought it has something to do with the software update. The guy there was always very helpful, he sincerely apologized and suggested that I should restart the car to see if it goes away. It didn't go away after the first restart, but something strange was happening - the car would not move when accelerated, and the ESC telltale was flashing like I was on some very slippery surface. I called the technician again, and he advised to take a break for the system to reset, which I just did. After 5-10 minutes, the car started normally, no errors whatsoever. It was very drivable. At least for a while... because now comes the near-death-experience moment... My route required to take a left on this busy national road. Keep in mind that this is a very busy road, with no central barrier, six lanes, and no traffic management in place, and the usual speeds are between 80 to 120 km/h. Turning left usually takes anywhere between one to even 10 minutes if you are unlucky or slow to take off. As I just said, I was waiting patiently at the intersection for a gap in the traffic, the gap came so I pressed the accelerator firmly. The car accelerated normally for a second, then it brake itself and stalled in the middle of the f#cking street. I heard the brakes of the other cars on the opposite lane, hurling towards me at 100km/h. All traffic got halted. I had to restart the car once again, this time it drove normally and I could clear the intersection. Luckily, nobody was hurt... But I've never been so embarrassed in my entire life. I drove the car back to the dealership. While driving, I contacted Ineos International Roadside Assistance, which was not so helpful, with no technicians immediately available on the phone, but at least someone from the tech called me later that day. I told him the story, the car was already at the Ineos dealership for investigations.

Apparently, a rock somehow managed to damage the wheel speed crown on the rear wheel , and the car would spiral into a meltdown.
This is the Ineos official ticket: AA1052865
The guys from the local dealership don't know how to handle this issue (warranty or not), so the car is grounded in the meantime.
Same communication issues from the BMW dealership to Ineos, it seems it's Ineos specific, which is a damn SHAME!
INEOS, get YOUR shit together, mate!

Later edit:
I apologize for not clearly specify why I think that Ineos doesn't care. It's because of repeated issues with communication and support, with dealerships, engineering and Ineos International Roadside Assistance. When people aped in to buy this vehicle (myself included), I think most of us did it because of the promises - modular vehicle, dependable, minimal non-interfering electronics, no bulls#it mechanics, no lock-ins and worldwide professional roadside assistance, including spare parts and access to highly trained professionals in case something goes south in the bush. In this particular case, the local dealership was unable to resolve the issue, and the car was grounded for indefinite time, with no clear direction on whether the repairs would be covered under warranty. At the dealership, there is a single person allowed to use the Ineos ordering software. This person is on vacation, so nobody knows anything, they are kind and apologetic, but not helpful. In a friendly chat, I was suggested to get a Toyota instead. The guys there all feel like Ineos pushed this vehicle down their throat without any vendor support whatsoever, they have no contact for spare parts, just a ordering software. NO CONTACT WHATSOEVER FROM INEOS. This kind of experience is frustrating for both dealerships and owners who expected the Grenadier to be a highly dependable, no-frills vehicle capable of handling tough conditions, and it creates the perception that Ineos is not responsive and responsible enough.
This problem reflects a deeper issue with the reliability of electronics in a vehicle that is supposed to be robust and capable of surviving tough, remote conditions, where such failures could be life-threatening. The lack of quick solutions or proactive communication has led to a feeling that Ineos is not prioritizing customers, as they should. In fact, I have no idea what they prioritize, and I even question if they actually exist and for how long. There are a lot of issues that were raised last year, that Ineos is aware about (at least the issues were communicated, nobody actually knows if or who they reached, and I sincerely question it's awareness):
- retrofit of critical components not available, even if they were paid when ordered the vehicle (vehicle came without): tow package, diesel water separator.
- No software updates to address critical corner cases that render the lockers unusable without resetting the vehicle.
- Not addressing the batteries burping acid on brake pipes.
- Not addressing the climate control erratic function.
- Not addressing airbag error on battery disconnect (only reset-able at dealership).
- Not addressing erratic headlight control and other random dings and dongs.
- Not addressing pointy hose clamps that pinch holes into other hoses they are in touch with.
- Not addressing bowden cables falling on the shaft.
- Not addressing the battery getting flat in camping when frequently opening doors.
- Not addressing exposed undercarriage components which have already been damaged (and have no place hanging low in an offroad vehicle) - radiators, lambdas, harnesses, abs rings, brake lines.
- Not addressing poor software development and bugs on systems like abs, offroad mode. Damn, even the fuel gauge was coded with a linear progression for an intricate designed fuel tank, which is the wrong way.

I know that some other cars might experience similar failure paths, but Ineos Grenadier was not advertised as a normal, off-the-shelf, car. It was designed (or, at least, advertised) as a specialized vehicle that won't stand in the way.
My trusty Land Cruiser 80 doesn't stand in my way. I don't get it, what's so freakin hard to get things right the way they were 30 years ago? Nobody forced Ineos to overcomplicate things to the point of not being able to figure out their own vehicles. Land Rover did it. Ford did it. Toyota did it with the 300 series, but I did not expect Ineos to do it. I really feel like Idiocracy is closer to a documentary than ever. The only mandatory facts were emissions. Surprisingly, they did an excellent job where they were constrained the most, because the powertrain is faultless.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_8175.jpeg
    IMG_8175.jpeg
    2.2 MB · Views: 294
  • 61356891-7591-4b99-be05-f2e6c703d939.jpeg
    61356891-7591-4b99-be05-f2e6c703d939.jpeg
    311.5 KB · Views: 293
  • 37c09a27-64fe-4484-b83e-abb74bc2871c.mov
    3.3 MB
  • 19deedf0-4059-4c5e-9432-a1870b849acf.jpeg
    19deedf0-4059-4c5e-9432-a1870b849acf.jpeg
    330.7 KB · Views: 288
  • c9bd7496-3f82-4d0f-b07b-fe19e8b964a5.jpeg
    c9bd7496-3f82-4d0f-b07b-fe19e8b964a5.jpeg
    357.7 KB · Views: 275
Last edited:

bemax

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
8:48 AM
Joined
May 12, 2022
Messages
2,543
Reaction score
4,956
Location
Germany
What a nasty experience! Luckily nothing severe happened! I understand that your trust in the car now is severely limited.
This would of course be my first reaction.
Nevertheless I did not understand why you think that Ineos does not care.
 

bikesandguitars

Grenadier Owner
Local time
12:48 AM
Joined
Jun 28, 2023
Messages
248
Reaction score
485
Location
Colorado
Well, it’s not like it didn’t try to warn you. 😜
Glad you’re safe.
Just to clarify; did the wheel speed sensor get damaged causing the braking systems to malfunction?
 

AWo

Local time
8:48 AM
Joined
Feb 28, 2023
Messages
1,057
Reaction score
1,974
Location
Germany
As bad as it is, but that could happen with any car. In our Defender Td4 the Turbo VTG actuator broke (300,000 km old). In that moment the car stalled as it lost power and the engine went into the emergency running mode.

And such a problem is not exclusively reserved for new cars with a lot of electronic. Even with my old Series 2a it is possible that the carburettor bars and rails fail just in such a bad moment.

AWo
 

Chadd7

Grenadier Owner
Local time
2:48 AM
Joined
May 17, 2023
Messages
601
Reaction score
807
Location
NJ, USA
I'm glad you're ok. This morning I was at a red light on a hill and my Gren was slow to fire back up when it turned green. Slight lag, but enough for me to roll backwards before the accelerator engaged. I find this a bit dangerous too.
 

anand

Photo Contest Winner
Forum Moderator
Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
2:48 AM
Joined
Mar 12, 2023
Messages
2,955
Reaction score
4,751
Location
Maryland
The guys from the local dealership don't know how to handle this issue (warranty or not), so the car is grounded in the meantime.
Same communication issues from the BMW dealership to Ineos, it seems it's Ineos specific, which is a damn SHAME!
INEOS, get YOUR shit together, mate!
The axles are Ineos specific, so it would make sense this is an Ineos specific part... As well, the same failure could have happened with any other vehicle that uses similar sensors.

An unfortunate instance, yes; but is not exclusive to the Grenadier
 
Local time
2:48 AM
Joined
Apr 28, 2023
Messages
944
Reaction score
844
Location
Pittsburgh
I had an Opel go into limp mode when I gunned it to merge onto the autobahn. That was an ass puckering moment. Near as I tell the auto stop/start kicked in at the same time as my left foot and the ecu said "fuckit I quit". There are an infinite amount of unpredictable scenarios that can occur when new technology is introduced. I hope you're a one off.
 

anand

Photo Contest Winner
Forum Moderator
Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
2:48 AM
Joined
Mar 12, 2023
Messages
2,955
Reaction score
4,751
Location
Maryland
I had an Opel go into limp mode when I gunned it to merge onto the autobahn. That was an ass puckering moment. Near as I tell the auto stop/start kicked in at the same time as my left foot and the ecu said "fuckit I quit". There are an infinite amount of unpredictable scenarios that can occur when new technology is introduced. I hope you're a one off.
Nearly rear ended a VW California yesterday in our brand new (was <300km when we picked it up) 2024 BMW M340i Touring rental.... The auto/start stop turns off the engine on decel, and as we got to the roundabout at the end of the off ramp (slip road for the Europeans) and just about to a stop, it decided to kick the engine back on again, which overpowered the amount of brake I was applying. Me then jamming on the brakes quickly engaged the auto-hold function and subsequently turned the engine off again. Same story with pulling into tight parking spots in car parks/garages, the auto start/stop and auto-hold brakes make it a nightmare to do small movements. And don't get me started on the far worse implementation of ADAS features in this BMW than anything else I've driven.

But I digress, back to cars dying when you're trying to pull out into traffic
 

alexandruast

Grenadier Owner
Local time
9:48 AM
Joined
Apr 2, 2024
Messages
89
Reaction score
195
Location
Romania
What a nasty experience! Luckily nothing severe happened! I understand that your trust in the car now is severely limited.
This would of course be my first reaction.
Nevertheless I did not understand why you think that Ineos does not care.
I apologize for not clearly specify why I think that Ineos doesn't care. It's because of repeated issues with communication and support, with dealerships, engineering and Ineos International Roadside Assistance. When people aped in to buy this vehicle (myself included), I think most of us did it because of the promises - modular vehicle, dependable, minimal non-interfering electronics, no bulls#it mechanics, no lock-ins and worldwide professional roadside assistance, including spare parts and access to highly trained professionals in case something goes south in the bush. In this particular case, the local dealership was unable to resolve the issue, and the car was grounded for indefinite time, with no clear direction on whether the repairs would be covered under warranty. At the dealership, there is a single person allowed to use the Ineos ordering software. This person is on vacation, so nobody knows anything, they are kind and apologetic, but not helpful. In a friendly chat, I was suggested to get a Toyota instead. The guys there all feel like Ineos pushed this vehicle down their throat without any vendor support whatsoever, they have no contact for spare parts, just a ordering software. NO CONTACT WHATSOEVER FROM INEOS. This kind of experience is frustrating for both dealerships and owners who expected the Grenadier to be a highly dependable, no-frills vehicle capable of handling tough conditions, and it creates the perception that Ineos is not responsive and responsible enough.
This problem reflects a deeper issue with the reliability of electronics in a vehicle that is supposed to be robust and capable of surviving tough, remote conditions, where such failures could be life-threatening. The lack of quick solutions or proactive communication has led to a feeling that Ineos is not prioritizing customers, as they should. In fact, I have no idea what they prioritize, and I even question if they actually exist and for how long. There are a lot of issues that were raised last year, that Ineos is aware about (at least the issues were communicated, nobody actually knows if or who they reached, and I sincerely question it's awareness):
- retrofit of critical components not available, even if they were paid when ordered the vehicle (vehicle came without): tow package, diesel water separator.
- No software updates to address critical corner cases that render the lockers unusable without resetting the vehicle.
- Not addressing the batteries burping acid on brake pipes.
- Not addressing the climate control erratic function.
- Not addressing airbag error on battery disconnect (only reset-able at dealership).
- Not addressing erratic headlight control and other random dings and dongs.
- Not addressing pointy hose clamps that pinch holes into other hoses they are in touch with.
- Not addressing bowden cables falling on the shaft.
- Not addressing the battery getting flat in camping when frequently opening doors.
- Not addressing exposed undercarriage components which have already been damaged (and have no place hanging low in an offroad vehicle) - radiators, lambdas, harnesses, abs rings, brake lines.
- Not addressing poor software development and bugs on systems like abs, offroad mode. Damn, even the fuel gauge was coded with a linear progression for an intricate designed fuel tank, which is the wrong way.

I know that some other cars might experience similar failure paths, but Ineos Grenadier was not advertised as a normal, off-the-shelf, car. It was designed (or, at least, advertised) as a specialized vehicle that won't stand in the way.
My trusty Land Cruiser 80 doesn't stand in my way. I don't get it, what's so freakin hard to get things right the way they were 30 years ago? Nobody forced Ineos to overcomplicate things to the point of not being able to figure out their own vehicles. Land Rover did it. Ford did it. Toyota did it with the 300 series, but I did not expect Ineos to do it. I really feel like Idiocracy is closer to a documentary than ever. The only mandatory facts were emissions. Surprisingly, they did an excellent job where they were constrained the most, because the powertrain is faultless.
 

alexandruast

Grenadier Owner
Local time
9:48 AM
Joined
Apr 2, 2024
Messages
89
Reaction score
195
Location
Romania
How many cars has Ineos sold in Romania?
I have no idea, mate. But based on the street occurrence of less than once a week while away from the dealership proximity, I would say between 100 and 500 vehicles in Romania at most.
 

LeeroyJ

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
10:48 AM
Joined
Oct 30, 2023
Messages
167
Reaction score
302
Location
Arizona, USA
Off topic, but keep this sort of scenario in mind (and the other stories in this thread) when you are tempted to road rage at someone doing something stupid on the road, its not always obvious what is causing someone to drive like a moron.
 
Last edited:
Local time
11:48 PM
Joined
Sep 26, 2023
Messages
329
Reaction score
214
Location
California, USA
Off topic, but keep this sort of scenario (and the other stories in this thread) when you are tempted to road rage at someone doing something stupid on the road, its not always obvious what is causing someone to drive like a moron.
Funny, that happened a few days back. I rarely honk my horn, maybe once every few years. I was about to honk my horn at somebody making a right hand turn but stopped for no reason...until the reason became clear....a bear was crossing the street but low enough I couldn't see it. Glad I paused:)
 

DaveB

Grenadier Owner
Local time
5:48 PM
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
7,433
Reaction score
15,139
Location
Toogoom, Fraser Coast Queensland
I keep seeing stories where people seem to misunderstand how warranty and business works.
Also dealers who aren't trained or had an Ineos dealership forced on them.
The dealer signs the agreement, Nobody from Ineos holds a gun to their head.
Only one person allowed to use the Ineos ordering system. That is the dealers decision, not Ineos.
My dealer said they only had two people trained and one was on leave and the other called in sick. My response was that when they knew the person was going on holiday they should have organised another person so they would still have two people trained.

Of course all modern vehicles need to have electronics, to expect otherwise is not realistic.
Ineos said they had minimised the quantity. 300 compared to LR Defender 3500

Not sure what is meant by Critical corner cases rendering lockers unuseable
 

alexandruast

Grenadier Owner
Local time
9:48 AM
Joined
Apr 2, 2024
Messages
89
Reaction score
195
Location
Romania
Of course all modern vehicles need to have electronics, to expect otherwise is not realistic.
Ineos said they had minimised the quantity. 300 compared to LR Defender 3500

Not sure what is meant by Critical corner cases rendering lockers unuseable
There is no intrinsec "need" for modern vehicles to have critical electronics, and I really expected this from Ineos, given the "specialized" mantra of this vehicle.
That's not to say that I don't appreciate electronics. I am an engineer and software programmer myself, working in DevOps and Security. I like technology, if I can use it to my advantage. But I dislike it if it stands in my way. And tech stays in the way of productivity more than ever, recently. It kinda shifted the normal perspective of "the ends justify the means". In today's world, I feel that tech becomes the only purpose. I am sorry, but I don't understand this.
The only required critical tech from a vehicle is maybe an ECU, but that's also questionable given that Toyota still sells the 1HZ engine in their 70-series, which is a naturally aspirated pure mechanical engine.
And there is a plethora of non-critical tech, with non-intrusive failure paths, I don't mind having in my vehicle - ABS, TPMS, Airbags, infotainment, maybe climate control (if it's failure path is manual mode), TCM if it's and Auto. But that's it. This is where the list ends, at least from my perspective in regard to a vehicle that advertises itself to be dependable.

Not sure what is meant by Critical corner cases rendering lockers unusable:
1. Enabling offroad mode sometimes makes the vehicle throw a "front locker button malfunction". After this error, you are unable to activate offroad mode, and you cannot use lockers if not in offroad mode. You have to stop the car and wait 10 minutes for the system to enter sleep mode and clear the errors.
2. Any error whatsoever prevents using offroad mode (so you are unable to use lockers).
3. Climbing a slippery steep hill sometimes requires power, momentum and lockers engaged. Ineos is automatically disengaging lockers past 50km/h, which will put the driver in an unfortunate situation of loosing momentum and rolling down uncontrollably.
All lockers should be usable no matter if the car is in Hi/Low and irrespective of other systems malfunction, except for the lockers malfunction themselves. A locker should never disengage by itself. An audible alarm of exceeding speed would be enough.

In a nutshell, a dependable vehicle should not make decisions for the driver. That's my point. I want to be in control. And Ineos promised exactly this when they presented the Grenadier.
 

AWo

Local time
8:48 AM
Joined
Feb 28, 2023
Messages
1,057
Reaction score
1,974
Location
Germany
You'll never achieve the emission goals in the US and EU without an ECU. Even the UPS, Unit Pump System, engines need an ECU to control up to three injections and they were the first engines with pre- and post injections.. You'll not achieve this with mechanical stuff. Toyota considers itself as a global mobility provider. Thererfore they have to sense what particular markets needs and what the regulations allow. The engines of Toyota you speak of can't be sold everywhere in the world, but they are still produced for countries where they are needed, can be maintained and the regulations allow them.

If you want to have an "old" Land Cruiser HZJ imported into the EU it must come with a base technology that allows to upgrade them to EU regulations. Companys like Tom's Fahrzeugtechnik or Nestle (not the food company) import these cars and modify them (in Germany). However, even in the countries they are produced, like South Africa, the regulations get tight. It is possible, that these good old engines will disappear, as well.

I personaly like the engines from the 1990ty years most. They were matured, flawless and had no environmental technology which harm the engine, require sensor technology and ECU's.
The company which from my point of view managed it best, to keep engines easy while fulfilling regulations is Mazda. With their Skyactive engine (compression+ignition petrol engine) they managed to match regulations without an EGR. But as it gets more and more tight, they will also hit the limits.

Other electronic stuff is simply required by law. I always get mad when I enter the Hilux and first of all I have to shut down all things which get me crazy before I can enjoy the ride. That's why I love it so much to drive with my Land Rover Series 2a....Get in, press the starter knob and go. A steering wheel, brakes, a speedo, a clutch and a gearbox, light and wipers. That's it.
❤️
 
Last edited:

Tazzieman

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Founding Guard
Local time
6:48 PM
Joined
Sep 30, 2021
Messages
6,685
Reaction score
13,277
Location
Tasmania
That's why I love it so much to drive with my Land Rover Series 2a....Get in, press the starter knob and go. A steering wheel, brakes, a speedo, a clutch and a gearbox, light and wipers. That's it.
❤️
Never a "limp home" mode.
Just a "fix it by the side of the road and onya way" mode!
But not for the faint hearted nor clean of fingernails ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom