Hi Andy!
Really great question! It comes down to personal preference I suppose. I have owned a couple Toyota vehicles over the years...1989 Supra Turbo, drove a Camry on and off for a year or so (solid sedan!), and a 2019 Toyota Tacoma OR that had a ton of mods that I did myself.
I love Toyota vehicles! I have been a fan for a long time. The build quality and reliability have been absolutely incredible over the years and having lived/deployed all over the globe to some really "not fun" places....I see Toyotas EVERYWHERE! And you know what? I could probably take some desert sand and dump it into the oil and it would probably still run solid! (Sarcasm but true to a point....the Toyota brand in my experience driving all across the globe for one thing or another they just simply run!). Here are my reasons for NOT going with the LC but I do believe it is an awesome vehicle but......
These are my own observations and MY opinions only so take them with a grain of salt and make your own choice:
1. Having owned/driven Toyota vehicles over the years I felt it was time for a change.
2. I was looking primarily for an off road vehicle that would be capable of the rock crawling/off roading I enjoy doing. The LC COULD fit that bill but see point 1.
3. We felt the looks of the LC were too similar to other vehicles on the market now within the price range we were looking at. YUP call my wife and I nuts but we loved the aesthetics of the Grenadier.
4. Both my wife and I were NOT sold on the Hybrid and the 4Cyl turbo. Probably all in our heads but if for some reason the battery crapped out I feel our towing abilities would be sorely limited (not sure if that is an issue at all but we were not willing to go that route).
That is about it to be fair. The LC just did not appeal to us. Nor did the Lexus GX550 simply for the aesthetics. I am POSITIVE they are both SOLID vehicles with a sound company standing behind them both but just not for us.
One contender was the LR Defender 110. Now that vehicle is REALLY REALLY nice! We test drove a couple of them and VERY PLUSH! However, I could not see myself wrenching on it much. I have never owned any JLR vehicles but although the LC is nice it simply did not fit what I wanted.
The Grenadier fits just about every box for our family. I also broke MY cardinal rule of purchasing a "first year" model and for that fact a "first year" USA introduction. You know what....rules were made to be broken.....LOL!
Time will tell if we made the right decision for us.
In the next week or so I will put up a post on our Grenadier thoughts and our purchase experience.
I do not think you can go wrong with many of the choices out there. The LC seems, from all the reviews out there, to be a solid vehicle and I would love to hear your thoughts when you test drive it. Also if you have tested or will test a Grenadier what your opinions between the two are.
Good luck in your search!
Mike