Well, ASPW will give an honest assessment of the product good and bad. It's his is opinion, sure, and I don't always agree with it, but it's direct none the less and you get input to consider for your own use. Scott and Overland Journal have a policy of not mentioning the bad. The industry pays his bills and puts the food on the table. Their articles read like ad copy. It's for entertainment only. It was kinda useless so I let the subscription die.
This may explain why he started a Q&A thread on Expedition portal in January, inviting questions, then went completely radio silent.