The Grenadier Forum
Register Now for enhanced site access.
INEOS Agents, Dealers or Commercial vendors please contact admin@theineosforum.com for a commercial account.

Automobilwoche states Recaro shutdown was due to Ineos

The automotive business magazin "Automobilwoche" states in an article from today that the shutdown of Ineos was in parallel to the insolvency of Recaro and not because. Insider said to Automobilwoche that in deed the lack of orders from Ineos lead to the shutdown of Recaro.

Quote: " “Of all the possible components, it was precisely a very important one,” commented Calder on the failure in the British newspaper “Daily Telegraph.” Ironically, the imbalance at Recaro is said to have been caused by a lack of quantities from the largest client, namely Ineos, according to sources within the company.

Recaro's bankruptcy has a significant impact. When asked why Ineos had not attempted to stabilize Recaro as a supplier with a financial injection, an Ineos spokesperson told Automobilwoche that they could not comment on individual business relationships, as it is a complex situation. The interruption in Hambach is expected to last for several months. “With cautious planning, a return to full production capacity is anticipated in spring 2025,” said the spokesperson. It remains unclear where Ineos will source the seats for the Grenadier, as Recaro is set to cease its production in Kirchheim/Teck by the end of the year. "

They also refer to a past interview from June 2024 with Lynn Calder where she stated a targeted unit numer of 30,000 and Automobilwoche also remembers Ineos statement that there has been 20 ,000 orders when the ramp up has started in 2023, but the first number hasn't been reached and even the latter number is missed, over two years, yet. They also refer to Marklines number of around 5,000 units for the USA and that is the best running market. They continue that the sales went down about 36% in Germany and one-third in Europe, compared to 2023.

In the last section they repeat what I stated here, also, that the image of the car has changed and that the marketing has to adopt that:

"Changed Marketing Strategy
Calder also had to adjust the marketing strategy to make the vehicle appealing to a broader customer base. Initially, the Grenadier was promoted for heavy-duty off-road use, targeting foresters, farmers, or NGOs operating in rugged terrain.

However, a marketing campaign during the European Football Championship emphasized the lifestyle aspect in order to expand the potential customer base. "From many conversations, I know that the off-road vehicle Grenadier, in connection with the name Ineos, is still not well known," said Calder."

Here is the link: https://www.automobilwoche.de/autohersteller/warum-ineos-automotive-gerade-probleme-hat
Payment required.

AWo
 
Last edited:

ADVAW8S

Global Grenadier 0044
Lifetime Supporter
Founding Guard
Local time
12:56 PM
Joined
Oct 11, 2021
Messages
1,989
Reaction score
2,915
Location
Kirkland, WA, USA
The automotive business magazin "Automobilwoche" states in an article from today that the shutdown of Ineos was in parallel to the insolvency of Recaro and not because. Insider said to Automobilwoche that in deed the lack of orders from Ineos lead to the shutdown of Recaro.

Quote: " “Of all the possible components, it was precisely a very important one,” commented Calder on the failure in the British newspaper “Daily Telegraph.” Ironically, the imbalance at Recaro is said to have been caused by a lack of quantities from the largest client, namely Ineos, according to sources within the company.

Recaro's bankruptcy has a significant impact. When asked why Ineos had not attempted to stabilize Recaro as a supplier with a financial injection, an Ineos spokesperson told Automobilwoche that they could not comment on individual business relationships, as it is a complex situation. The interruption in Hambach is expected to last for several months. “With cautious planning, a return to full production capacity is anticipated in spring 2025,” said the spokesperson. It remains unclear where Ineos will source the seats for the Grenadier, as Recaro is set to cease its production in Kirchheim/Teck by the end of the year. "

They also refer to a past interview from June 2024 with Lynn Calder where she stated a targeted unit numer of 30,000 and Automobilwoche also remembers Ineos statement that there has been 20 ,000 orders when the ramp up has started in 2023, but the first number hasn't been reached and even the latter number is missed, over two years, yet. They also refer to Marklines number of around 5,000 units for the USA and that is the best running market. They continue that the sales went down about 36% in Germany and one-third in Europe, compared to 2023.

In the last section they repeat what I stated here, also, that the image of the car has changed and that the marketing has to adopt that:

"Changed Marketing Strategy
Calder also had to adjust the marketing strategy to make the vehicle appealing to a broader customer base. Initially, the Grenadier was promoted for heavy-duty off-road use, targeting foresters, farmers, or NGOs operating in rugged terrain.

However, a marketing campaign during the European Football Championship emphasized the lifestyle aspect in order to expand the potential customer base. "From many conversations, I know that the off-road vehicle Grenadier, in connection with the name Ineos, is still not well known," said Calder."

Here is the link: https://www.automobilwoche.de/autohersteller/warum-ineos-automotive-gerade-probleme-hat
Payment required.

AWo
I used the paywall clear and pulled this translated quote.
The largest market is the USA
Things are going better for the Grenadier in the USA. The country has quickly become the largest market. Since entering the market last autumn, sales have settled at over 500 units per month, and this year it is already almost 5,000
Nevertheless, that is not enough to really utilize production in Hambach. While Lynn Calder had spoken of a possible 30,000 units for 2024 in an interview with Automobilwoche in June of this year, the figure is now expected to be 10,000 less.
 

ADVAW8S

Global Grenadier 0044
Lifetime Supporter
Founding Guard
Local time
12:56 PM
Joined
Oct 11, 2021
Messages
1,989
Reaction score
2,915
Location
Kirkland, WA, USA
This article leads me to believe that Lynn Calder will be doing some big retooling during the shutdown. I can see them move dealership models. I could even see IFS be added. You figure they already did majority of the work for Fussilier, it might be easy for them to implement in the 2026 model. Develop a campaign that drives attention and squash the negative feedback loop.
 
Local time
3:56 PM
Joined
Apr 28, 2023
Messages
1,005
Reaction score
879
Location
Pittsburgh
The only “fact” I pulled from this, is “spring”. Thats March, April or May, and vague timelines tend to emphasize the optimistic.

On the other hand, if it isn’t all bullshit, this means we’re gonna get a better seat we can swap into the rig.
 

DoubleDoom

Grenadier Owner
Forum Donor
Local time
8:56 PM
Joined
Apr 10, 2024
Messages
122
Reaction score
219
Location
UK
I still do not believe Ineos were the major supplier with Recaro. BMW, Ford and VW all had options in their range for Recaro seats. If Ineos was the biggest, then Recaro were doomed long before this point.
 

CrazyOldMan

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
Mar 13, 2024
Messages
529
Reaction score
525
Location
Wisconsin, USA
The automotive business magazin "Automobilwoche" states in an article from today that the shutdown of Ineos was in parallel to the insolvency of Recaro and not because. Insider said to Automobilwoche that in deed the lack of orders from Ineos lead to the shutdown of Recaro.

Quote: " “Of all the possible components, it was precisely a very important one,” commented Calder on the failure in the British newspaper “Daily Telegraph.” Ironically, the imbalance at Recaro is said to have been caused by a lack of quantities from the largest client, namely Ineos, according to sources within the company.

Recaro's bankruptcy has a significant impact. When asked why Ineos had not attempted to stabilize Recaro as a supplier with a financial injection, an Ineos spokesperson told Automobilwoche that they could not comment on individual business relationships, as it is a complex situation. The interruption in Hambach is expected to last for several months. “With cautious planning, a return to full production capacity is anticipated in spring 2025,” said the spokesperson. It remains unclear where Ineos will source the seats for the Grenadier, as Recaro is set to cease its production in Kirchheim/Teck by the end of the year. "

They also refer to a past interview from June 2024 with Lynn Calder where she stated a targeted unit numer of 30,000 and Automobilwoche also remembers Ineos statement that there has been 20 ,000 orders when the ramp up has started in 2023, but the first number hasn't been reached and even the latter number is missed, over two years, yet. They also refer to Marklines number of around 5,000 units for the USA and that is the best running market. They continue that the sales went down about 36% in Germany and one-third in Europe, compared to 2023.

In the last section they repeat what I stated here, also, that the image of the car has changed and that the marketing has to adopt that:

"Changed Marketing Strategy
Calder also had to adjust the marketing strategy to make the vehicle appealing to a broader customer base. Initially, the Grenadier was promoted for heavy-duty off-road use, targeting foresters, farmers, or NGOs operating in rugged terrain.

However, a marketing campaign during the European Football Championship emphasized the lifestyle aspect in order to expand the potential customer base. "From many conversations, I know that the off-road vehicle Grenadier, in connection with the name Ineos, is still not well known," said Calder."

Here is the link: https://www.automobilwoche.de/autohersteller/warum-ineos-automotive-gerade-probleme-hat
Payment required.

AWo
I think I’m all good for now with Recaro’s whining. To suggest that Ineos order volume is the thing that put them in this situation is such a load of garbage. Recaro put themselves in this niche, they’ve lost all their customers, and they are trying to put on a good face to get/force a rescue. It’s a classic bankruptcy dance. Ineos shouldn’t try to rescue them if they can get out with a spec and an alternative fabricator. It’s not a rosy picture for German automotive suppliers who don’t have a defensible unique space. I would not want to be left holding that bag if I were Ineos.
 

AWo

Local time
9:56 PM
Joined
Feb 28, 2023
Messages
1,078
Reaction score
2,018
Location
Germany
It is documented that Recaro was struggling for about two years.

That, again, leads to the question why Ineos went with such a candidate for such an essential part? I did a project for Ineos about 10 years ago, a mid-size 6-digit budget and all suppliers had to pass a solvency check... The misery of Recaro was foreseeable and known within the industry. All other car manufacturers used Recaro only as an option, so they do not get into trouble if they die and can easy replace seats (just not offering Recaro anymore). Not so Ineos.

Two years of time wasted to find an alternative supplier...if it wasn't Ineos which caused the insolvency.

However, I believe that missing Ineos orders were the death blow for Recaro. And missing orders are due to ow sales numbers and means low earnings and that means more problems.

AWo
 
Local time
3:56 PM
Joined
Apr 28, 2023
Messages
1,005
Reaction score
879
Location
Pittsburgh
Volume pricing requires the volume. I’m not so sure what’s so hard to comprehend. If you’re running a lab and the instrument you just bought from Leica has a reagent deal for 100000 tests a year for 5 years, and you only run 40000, Leica is losing money on you and burning it down. If you’re were their only customer, they burn down. That’s how it works.

Now, why Ineos would make this deal is a mystery we will never know for certain, but, I’m guessing it has to with money. Maybe Recaro went from the premium seat to the only seat by circumstance rod Ineos trying to cut supply costs and it but them in the ass when sales targets could not reach the break even point. Maybe the original Ineos deal was the “save Recaro” deal in the first place, and it failed.
 

CrazyOldMan

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
Mar 13, 2024
Messages
529
Reaction score
525
Location
Wisconsin, USA
Th
It is documented that Recaro was struggling for about two years.

That, again, leads to the question why Ineos went with such a candidate for such an essential part? I did a project for Ineos about 10 years ago, a mid-size 6-digit budget and all suppliers had to pass a solvency check... The misery of Recaro was foreseeable and known within the industry. All other car manufacturers used Recaro only as an option, so they do not get into trouble if they die and can easy replace seats (just not offering Recaro anymore). Not so Ineos.

Two years of time wasted to find an alternative supplier...if it wasn't Ineos which caused the insolvency.

However, I believe that missing Ineos orders were the death blow for Recaro. And missing orders are due to ow sales numbers and means low earnings and that means more problems.

AWo
That’s fair - maybe the final blow - but crazy that Ineos didn’t de-risk the supplier situation (and maybe a bit of a convenience cover for now), and pathetic that this would have been the only thing keeping Recaro from insolvency. I guess it will be a little more clear in a few months. I’m here in Germany for work right now - it’s definitely been more fun. Also a lot worse - but you can feel the pressure and see the belt tightening. Cost profile was never the strong suit over here, and they know it. Recaro is just more roadkill on this ride. I’m ready to go home. Uffda.
 

TD5-90

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Founding Guard
Local time
9:56 PM
Joined
Aug 22, 2021
Messages
436
Reaction score
912
Location
South Germany
Th

That’s fair - maybe the final blow - but crazy that Ineos didn’t de-risk the supplier situation (and maybe a bit of a convenience cover for now), and pathetic that this would have been the only thing keeping Recaro from insolvency. I guess it will be a little more clear in a few months. I’m here in Germany for work right now - it’s definitely been more fun. Also a lot worse - but you can feel the pressure and see the belt tightening. Cost profile was never the strong suit over here, and they know it. Recaro is just more roadkill on this ride. I’m ready to go home. Uffda.
May I ask which industry you're involved in and what you're doing around here in sick Germany?
 
Last edited:

255/85

Grenadier Owner
Forum Donor
Local time
12:56 PM
Joined
Mar 4, 2023
Messages
727
Reaction score
818
Location
Western U.S.
Ineos may have been overly enthusiastic with sales projections but I still think Recaro lured them in with midnight hooker prices. I'm willing to bet that Ineos originally wanted to go with Scheel-Mann. In Stuttgart. C'mon, it's only 160k away.
 
Local time
3:56 PM
Joined
Apr 28, 2023
Messages
1,005
Reaction score
879
Location
Pittsburgh
Ineos may have been overly enthusiastic with sales projections but I still think Recaro lured them in with midnight hooker prices. I'm willing to bet that Ineos originally wanted to go with Scheel-Mann. In Stuttgart. C'mon, it's only 160k away.
An option for vario xxl's would have made my privates warm an fuzzy.
 

CrazyOldMan

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
Mar 13, 2024
Messages
529
Reaction score
525
Location
Wisconsin, USA
May I ask which industry you're involved in and what you're doing around here in sick Germany?
Mostly WMD and human trafficking. In all seriousness, med tech and pharma. It is interesting, though, because I have a lot of colleagues who came out of automotive here in Germany. I’ve been coming out for many, many years. I can just feel the anxiety right now, and see it in the numbers. Like I said - ready to head home. Rough week. Maybe I should just skip the roads and drive through the fields on my way home from the airport tomorrow. That would lift my spirits (but probably get me shot or arrested).
 

CrazyOldMan

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
2:56 PM
Joined
Mar 13, 2024
Messages
529
Reaction score
525
Location
Wisconsin, USA
A
I'll bring the Jamisons to liven it u
Actually this sounds pretty good - a trans-Atlantic meet up in Germany. I’m not sure seeing Zimm’s warm fuzzy naughty parts is exactly the way I would go for the itinerary, but a Jamison’s isn’t a bad idea. Has someone mapped out to see if members in Germany are at all close to one another, or spread out all over?
 
Local time
3:56 PM
Joined
Apr 28, 2023
Messages
1,005
Reaction score
879
Location
Pittsburgh
A


Actually this sounds pretty good - a trans-Atlantic meet up in Germany. I’m not sure seeing Zimm’s warm fuzzy naughty parts is exactly the way I would go for the itinerary, but a Jamison’s isn’t a bad idea. Has someone mapped out to see if members in Germany are at all close to one another, or spread out all over?
Suuuuure.....
 
Back
Top Bottom