The Grenadier Forum
Register Now for enhanced site access.
INEOS Agents, Dealers or Commercial vendors please contact admin@theineosforum.com for a commercial account.

Questions, questions, questions, any help?

Paco Garcia

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local Group Moderator
Local time
3:04 AM
Joined
May 13, 2023
Messages
220
Reaction score
401
Location
Valencia (España)
As many of you have read, on October 29th the Dana left me without a car. I have no idea how long it will take until I am compensated for the total loss of the vehicle, nor how much it will be, but what is clear is that I will have plenty of time to think about what to do. If this had not happened, I would never have considered changing the car, since even with its constant false warnings, problems with the wheel sensors and some other software nonsense, I love the car. But having to start from scratch due to a situation beyond my control, I have many doubts, more related to the AI problems than to the car itself.

Facts:

The Ineos factory is closed, “Provisionally” Until ……….

What they tell us is that they have problems with a supplier, which forces them to stop production.

The supplier says that their problems are caused by Ineos not buying the agreed volumes. This has decapitalised them and caused them to go bankrupt.

Ineos is not selling the number of cars that it had planned. In two years it has not reached the number that it had planned to sell annually.

Sales in Europe have been very, very low compared to initial forecasts.

In Spain, barely 40 units have been sold.

The decision not to manufacture the Fusilier, or any other electric car, harms the tax burden on the production of the Granadier.

The multiple software problems have harmed the reputation of the Granadier.

The sales system has not pleased the Dealers.

The AI promises have not been fulfilled. ease of obtaining parts, self-repair by the vehicle owner “Workshop Manual”, excessive delay in spare parts, impossibility of resetting maintenance periods, delay and non-existence in the usual channels for replacement of windshields, inoperative customer service, lack of information. etc, etc, etc.

As you can see, I am referring to the current situation of INEOS Automotive, NOT the car, which has been gradually solving most of the initial problems, but in light of all the above I cannot help but think that there is much more than what they are telling us, which does not necessarily have to be bad, but when there is not enough information, doubts appear.

Personal reflections:

I think that Ineos Automotive needed a Stand by, to reconsider what to do (beyond the seats) in the face of the accumulation of circumstances previously mentioned and to find complex solutions to the problems it is currently having. Being very positive and optimistic, perhaps it should be considering:
. Fulfilling what it promised.
. Improving the Software.
. perhaps adding a mild-hybrid system that allows it to have less tax pressure.
. Changing the model of the current sales system, making real concessions to distributors, and increasing the number of dealers.
. Changing the current standard of models starting with a cheaper “Basic” model as an entry point, which will help increase sales, not everyone who likes the image of the Grenadier needs its exceptional performance.
. Getting a commercial model that does not have problems in recovering VAT.
. etc, etc.

Given all this, I have to consider what to do, I know what you are going to tell me, as it could not be otherwise, and thinking with my heart I think the same, get another Grenadier, but if I think with reason the thing is much more complex, since I cannot ignore that:

Is IA trying to solve what is being raised? or it simply does not know what to do and is questioning the profitability/continuity of the project.
The largest market for Ineos so far has been the USA. A potential increase in tariffs would weigh on the decisions to be made.
In Europe, taxes on this type of Vehicle are skyrocketing in a brutal way. making it almost impossible to buy.
If IA is trying to solve the problems, and I hope it is, how long can it take to address these problems?
Would you buy an Ineos from the dealerships if you thought that they would be improved in some way in a short time? Software, Adas, etc., and that it will also surely be difficult to find one in Spain that suits what you are looking for (there are very few units).
My dealership, which is about 30 km away, is considering ceasing to be one, given the poor sales of the vehicle and the problems of all kinds that it is having with IA. If in the end it disappears as an Ineos dealership, the closest one will be 350 km from my house.

Well, I am aware that I have given you a good piece of shit, but my head does not stop, and I needed to tell my concerns to someone who understands what I am talking about, and who better than you to do it. Tell me what you think, your honest opinion on what is happening with IA, if you think I am totally wrong and it is the result of frustration for losing the car. At the moment I am clear on what I have to do and that is to wait for the resolution of the accident. Beyond that, there are only doubts.

A hug, friends.

Paco Garcia
 

Skydance

Grenadier Owner
Local time
2:04 AM
Joined
May 16, 2023
Messages
480
Reaction score
602
Location
MANCHESTER
At the end of the day, if you don’t live reasonably near a dealer, then I would not have one. It simply isn’t practical, no matter what brand it is (especially if it’s going to be a daily driver or your only mode of transport).
 

landmannnn

Grenadier Owner
Local time
2:04 AM
Joined
Apr 9, 2024
Messages
694
Reaction score
1,118
Location
UK
I think you might be better off making things a lot simpler.

Things we already know.... For example the factory is currently closed, some European governments are anti-car because the EU said so, (one other thing the EU said has had devastating consequences in Spain as you know)

Things we shouldn't worry about..
Sales figures, cashflow, (Ineos have nearly spent more money on Manchester United than IA), tariffs etc. People are paid to worry about those.

Things we don't know... Workshop manuals, changes to reduce faults etc

Things we would like to see... Everything from Dana axles, better software, cheaper specs, more expensive specs, V8s etc

Should you get another IG? Yes, but my mind is already made up.
 

CrazyOldMan

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
8:04 PM
Joined
Mar 13, 2024
Messages
673
Reaction score
682
Location
Wisconsin, USA
I think you might be better off making things a lot simpler.

Things we already know.... For example the factory is currently closed, some European governments are anti-car because the EU said so, (one other thing the EU said has had devastating consequences in Spain as you know)

Things we shouldn't worry about..
Sales figures, cashflow, (Ineos have nearly spent more money on Manchester United than IA), tariffs etc. People are paid to worry about those.

Things we don't know... Workshop manuals, changes to reduce faults etc

Things we would like to see... Everything from Dana axles, better software, cheaper specs, more expensive specs, V8s etc

Should you get another IG? Yes, but my mind is already made up.
Paco - I’m with @landmannnn on this. If you’re still determined to stick with your original purpose (body on frame, 2 live axles with triple locks, built to survive the Apocalypse), you really only have the Grenadier. If your recent experience has changed your appetite for risk (and that would COMPLETELY make sense - no judgement here!!!), then no, don’t make extra anxiety for yourself. You could do a JLR Defender or the new Toyota LC - not as robust but less to worry about.
 

CRH

Grenadier Owner
Local time
2:04 AM
Joined
Mar 5, 2024
Messages
363
Reaction score
433
Location
United Kingdom
If you are a worrier and don't need all the extreme off road stuff and the IFS is suitable for your needs, then go for the Toyota. If you are order new replacement then the worry of IA not opening and the vehicles not having backup won't be an issue as you will only get one if it does. If they have shut to rectify some issues, then even better for you with a new vehicle, I am sure they will be working on this whilst they have the time to.
I like you, worry about these things and with IA being a new company it is always going to be a worry, Fisker went bust, but electric vehicles are so much more expensive to develop/produce. IA have plenty of money, not there to loose money, but I am fairly sure that they will make it work, hence aiming for the high value limited edition models which will bring in some much needed cash. Fingers crossed all round and good luck to you in getting sorted out sooner rather than later
 

Clark Kent

Grenadier Owner
Lifetime Supporter
Local time
12:04 PM
Joined
Jul 26, 2022
Messages
755
Reaction score
1,848
Location
Toowoomba QLD, Australia
As many of you have read, on October 29th the Dana left me without a car. I have no idea how long it will take until I am compensated for the total loss of the vehicle, nor how much it will be, but what is clear is that I will have plenty of time to think about what to do. If this had not happened, I would never have considered changing the car, since even with its constant false warnings, problems with the wheel sensors and some other software nonsense, I love the car. But having to start from scratch due to a situation beyond my control, I have many doubts, more related to the AI problems than to the car itself.

Facts:

The Ineos factory is closed, “Provisionally” Until ……….

What they tell us is that they have problems with a supplier, which forces them to stop production.

The supplier says that their problems are caused by Ineos not buying the agreed volumes. This has decapitalised them and caused them to go bankrupt.

Ineos is not selling the number of cars that it had planned. In two years it has not reached the number that it had planned to sell annually.

Sales in Europe have been very, very low compared to initial forecasts.

In Spain, barely 40 units have been sold.

The decision not to manufacture the Fusilier, or any other electric car, harms the tax burden on the production of the Granadier.

The multiple software problems have harmed the reputation of the Granadier.

The sales system has not pleased the Dealers.

The AI promises have not been fulfilled. ease of obtaining parts, self-repair by the vehicle owner “Workshop Manual”, excessive delay in spare parts, impossibility of resetting maintenance periods, delay and non-existence in the usual channels for replacement of windshields, inoperative customer service, lack of information. etc, etc, etc.

As you can see, I am referring to the current situation of INEOS Automotive, NOT the car, which has been gradually solving most of the initial problems, but in light of all the above I cannot help but think that there is much more than what they are telling us, which does not necessarily have to be bad, but when there is not enough information, doubts appear.

Personal reflections:

I think that Ineos Automotive needed a Stand by, to reconsider what to do (beyond the seats) in the face of the accumulation of circumstances previously mentioned and to find complex solutions to the problems it is currently having. Being very positive and optimistic, perhaps it should be considering:
. Fulfilling what it promised.
. Improving the Software.
. perhaps adding a mild-hybrid system that allows it to have less tax pressure.
. Changing the model of the current sales system, making real concessions to distributors, and increasing the number of dealers.
. Changing the current standard of models starting with a cheaper “Basic” model as an entry point, which will help increase sales, not everyone who likes the image of the Grenadier needs its exceptional performance.
. Getting a commercial model that does not have problems in recovering VAT.
. etc, etc.

Given all this, I have to consider what to do, I know what you are going to tell me, as it could not be otherwise, and thinking with my heart I think the same, get another Grenadier, but if I think with reason the thing is much more complex, since I cannot ignore that:

Is IA trying to solve what is being raised? or it simply does not know what to do and is questioning the profitability/continuity of the project.
The largest market for Ineos so far has been the USA. A potential increase in tariffs would weigh on the decisions to be made.
In Europe, taxes on this type of Vehicle are skyrocketing in a brutal way. making it almost impossible to buy.
If IA is trying to solve the problems, and I hope it is, how long can it take to address these problems?
Would you buy an Ineos from the dealerships if you thought that they would be improved in some way in a short time? Software, Adas, etc., and that it will also surely be difficult to find one in Spain that suits what you are looking for (there are very few units).
My dealership, which is about 30 km away, is considering ceasing to be one, given the poor sales of the vehicle and the problems of all kinds that it is having with IA. If in the end it disappears as an Ineos dealership, the closest one will be 350 km from my house.

Well, I am aware that I have given you a good piece of shit, but my head does not stop, and I needed to tell my concerns to someone who understands what I am talking about, and who better than you to do it. Tell me what you think, your honest opinion on what is happening with IA, if you think I am totally wrong and it is the result of frustration for losing the car. At the moment I am clear on what I have to do and that is to wait for the resolution of the accident. Beyond that, there are only doubts.

A hug, friends.

Paco Garcia

I appreciate you sharing your thoughts under difficult personal circumstances Paco. It's an uncomfortable but balanced read. Great input from the others guys.

How well was the Grenadier meeting your expectations, including the ownership experience? If you were happy with how things were going and fell in love with the whole package then you will have a desire to restore what you had. A decision from the heart as you say.
If you have any lingering disappointments about your Grenadier experience then you should use this moment as an opportunity to recover your investment and do something else. Don't waste this moment and don't rush it. It's a chance to start over if that idea appeals to you at all.

If you choose Box B, be very sure you're not going backwards. When my wife asks her married girlfriends "Does a perfect one even exist?", I'm absolutely sure she is referring to 4WDs.
 

Tom109

Grenadier Owner
Local time
9:04 PM
Joined
Jun 3, 2023
Messages
1,626
Reaction score
2,262
Location
New Jersey, USA
Paco - sorry to read of your Dana troubles, and hope the compensation comes through.

My Grenadier decision came down to this, what is my other option? In North America there isn’t another vehicle in the full time 4wd, overbuilt/durable category I would consider.
 

GN4HIR

Forum Donor
Local time
8:04 PM
Joined
May 5, 2024
Messages
176
Reaction score
248
Location
Houston, TX, USA
Paco, your post is well thought out and summarizes the concerns of many here. As I'm in the USA, I see them still adding dealers here and we have good inventories. I agree with Skydance, if you don't end up with a dealer within a reasonable distance it would a more risky proposition. I'm very lucky to be close to my dealer. I don't know if I picked up on it but is this your only vehicle? That would also be an issue as some of repairs are taking an excessive period of time to fix due to lack of spares. Could you afford to be without it for weeks if there was a significant repair.

I think a lot of the concerns could be laid to rest if IA were more transparent with the sentiment of ownership and a plan forward. I think Jim should give a state of the company speech or at least letter, to owners.
 
Back
Top Bottom